Another single-family rental (SFR) securitization deal sponsored by a large institutional player, Progress Residential, is slated to hit the private-label market this month, bringing the total securitization-deal count for Progress to seven so far this year.

This latest transaction, Progress 2022-SFR7, will be secured by a single $426.8 million fixed-rate loan backed by mortgages on 1,434 single-family rental (SFR) homes. The deal represents Progress’ 36th securitization to date, with a total note issuance of $20.5 billion, according to a bond-presale report by the Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA).

The homes in SFR mortgage pool backing the note to be issued through the securitization are in 11 states, but the three largest state exposures account for nearly 76% of the portfolio, with Florida leading the pack (32.1%) followed by Texas (28.0%) and Georgia (15.3%). 

“The largest five exposures [at the metro level] account for 59.2% of the total property count and include Atlanta (235 homes, 16.4%) … followed by Houston (179, 12.5%); Jacksonville (168, 11.7%); Orlando (150, 10.5%); and Dallas (117, 8.2%),” KBRA’s presale report on the offering states.

The Progress Residential SFR offering is the most recent deal in a sector that has been red hot this year. The volume and number of SFR securitization transactions this year to date already exceeds total issuances for all of 2021.

Last year, there was a total of nine SFR transactions involving 30,471 income-producing single-family rental properties valued at $7.7 billion at issuance, according to deal data tracked by KBRA. Year to date through mid-September, KBRA has tracked 13 institutional-sponsored private-label securitization transactions involving 30,247 single-family rental-properties valued at $9.1 billion. 

These SFR securitizations are often referred to as Wall Street deals because they involve large corporations that own thousands of rental properties. The notes issued in the institutional SFR deals are typically collateralized by a single loan, which is in turn secured by a large pool of mortgages on income-producing single-family homes. 

Since the initial SFR securitization in 2013 through August of this year, according to a separate KBRA market-sector report, 16 sponsors have undertaken 113 SFR securitizations involving notes with a total principal balance of $69.6 billion. At issuance, the notes in those SFR transactions were collateralized by some 355,000 underlying properties. That doesn’t include Progress Residential’s latest offering, which would bump the deal count to 114 and push the note total past $70 billion.

“The business model for large-scale institutional ownership and management of SFR properties in the U.S. was born out of the Great Recession of 2008,” the KBRA presale report states. “… The sector’s inaugural transaction was eventually issued by Invitation Homes in November 2013. 

“The securitization, IH 2013-SFR1, was collateralized by a single $479.1 million floating rate loan secured by first mortgages on 3,207 income-producing SFR homes.”

The KBRA SFR sector report, called “SFR Securitizations: A Decade in the Making,” reveals that the bulk of the outstanding note issuance as of the end of August can be attributed to four issuers, “each of whom have more than $5 billion outstanding.” Those issuers, and their outstanding note balances from SFR securitizations, are Progress Residential, $14.1 billion; FirstKey Homes, $10 billion; Amherst Residential, $6.3 billion and Home Partners of America, $5.2 billion.

The 11 currently active institutional issuers in the SFR market owned or managed in total an estimated 390,000 properties as of the end of August, according to the KBRA sector report. Progress Residential and Invitation Homes led the pack at 83,000 SFR properties each, followed by American Homes 4 Rent, 58,700; FirstKey Homes, 44,500; Amherst Residential, 42,000; and Tricon Residential, 33,000.

Although the institutional SFR market has proven a lucrative play in recent years, there are headwinds on the horizon, according to the KBRA bond-presale report. The report points out that the performance of the sector historically has benefited from a period of strong economic growth marked by increasing rents and home prices.

“However, the asset class is now being subjected to economic and geopolitical disruptions,” the KBRA report continues. “Additionally, rising interest rates may put downward pressure on home prices, and inflation may put pressure on operating margins. 

“Should home prices, rental rates, and/or operating margins decline meaningfully, the sector could come under a stress that it has not previously endured.”

The KBRA SFR sector report states that if such a scenario developed, the workout could be problematic for those affected. “The customized nature of the loan and related collateral may limit the universe of buyers willing to purchase the loan in a distressed situation, and substantial workout negotiations may be required to restructure the loan,” the report states.

In addition, KBRA points out that the institutional SFR sector has come under increasing governmental scrutiny over concerns that it is impacting home affordability and prices in some areas of the country.

In fact, institutional players in the SFR market were recently the targets of a congressional hearing in which they faced accusations of gentrifying minority neighborhoods and allegedly displacing large numbers of people of color — Black residents in particular. 

“Securitized SFR homes are heavily clustered in the Sunbelt, which comprises the Southeastern, Southwestern and Western U.S. region, and in communities that previously experienced high foreclosure rates following the 2008 financial crisis,” a report introduced at the congressional hearing states. “For example, in the third quarter of 2021 alone, institutional investors bought 42.8% of homes for sale in the Atlanta metro area and 38.8% of homes in the Phoenix-Glendale-Scottsdale area.” 

In addition to the onset of volatile market conditions not faced by the institutional SFR market previously and the scrutiny at the federal level, KBRA’s sector report notes that there are headwinds developing at the local level as well for the industry.

“There also are some efforts at the grassroot level by homeowner associations and local municipalities on adding restrictions on acquiring and operating single-family properties for rental purposes,” the KBRA report states. “All of the above could result in a wide range of outcomes (legislative or otherwise) that could negatively impact the industry’s growth and/or performance.”

Institutional ownership in the overall SFR sector is estimated to represent only around 2% of the market currently, a market insight report from MetLife Investment Management (MIM) states. Most SFR properties nationwide are now owned by smaller mom-and-pop landlords,

MIM predicts, however, that institutional SFR ownership Is poised to expand significantly over the decade — assuming the sector can overcome the headwinds now on the horizon. That growth, if it materializes, bodes well for the growth of the private-label securitization market.

“MIM’s analysis indicates that simply moving institutional ownership of SFR from 2% today to 10% [of the investment-property market] in the future will result in a need for over $200 billion in incremental debt financing,” MIM’s market insight report states.

The post Progress Residential unveils 36th private-label SFR offering  appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


The economic standoff between rising inflation and rising interest rates continues to weaken the housing market nationwide, with home sales falling across all 12 Federal Reserve districts, according to the Fed’s latest Beige Book report.

Prospects for future improvement anytime soon are dim as well. “The outlook for future economic growth remained generally weak, with … expectations for further softening of demand over the next six to 12 months,” the report states.

Financial advisory firm Mortgage Capital Trading (MCT) notes that the strong inflation numbers released yesterday, September 13, make it likely that the Federal Reserve will be more aggressive in its next round of rate hikes. The Fed’s Federal Open Market Committee is slated to meet July 26-27.

“A 75 basis-point move is being priced in by markets, with some anticipating upwards of a full point,” MCT’s daily market commentary states. “Mortgage applications have dropped by 29% since the same time last year as rates continue to climb, curbing demand. 

“With the average 30-year fixed rate at or near 6% or more, rates have literally doubled over the course of the past year… There are only about 452,000 borrowers eligible for a beneficial refinance according to a large mortgage data provider. Refinance applications are 83% lower than last year.”

A recent market report by digital mortgage exchange and loan aggregator MAXEX notes that the ongoing economic volatility “has had a profound effect on the housing industry.”

“Rapidly rising interest rates and skyrocketing home prices pushed many would-be buyers out of the market and tanked the refinance market,” the MAXEX report states.

Following are excerpts of statements on housing conditions from each of the 12 Federal Reserve districts — drawn from the recently released Federal Reserve Beige Book. The Beige Book reports, published eight times a year, are based on interviews with bank directors, business and community organization leaders, economists, market experts and other sources. 

The information and data for the current Beige Book — released in September — was collected on or before August 29. The prior Beige Book report, released in July, was based on information collected on or before July 13. The next Beige Book report is slated to be released on October 19.

***

Boston — Higher interest rates cooled home-buying demand, leading to fewer closed sales in the First District’s residential real estate markets. … Closed sales fell sharply over the year in all reporting markets in a notable weakening from the previous report. Contacts attributed the decline in sales to rising mortgage rates, coupled with high price inflation that crimped buyers’ budgets. Home prices increased over the year in all reporting markets. For single-family homes, the over-the-year price increase was smaller than in the previous report, and contacts anticipated that prices would continue to level off into the fall. In condo markets, the price increases were slightly larger than or on par with those from the previous report. Since the spring, inventories were substantially lower in Rhode Island, Maine, and Vermont, but moderately higher in Massachusetts (including Boston proper) and New Hampshire. Several contacts described a return to pre-pandemic normalcy in the market after the home-buying “frenzy” of the past two years.

New York — The home sales market has softened over the summer, while the rental market has continued to strengthen. In New York City, as well as across most of the district, homes sales tapered off, and the inventory of available homes, though still very low, edged higher. Home prices appear to have leveled off across most of the region and the prevalence of bidding wars has receded noticeably. 

Philadelphia — Homebuilders reported that contract signings for new homes continued to fall modestly. However, contacts noted that sales traffic rebounded slightly in recent weeks following the introduction of new incentives and lower-priced options. Existing-home sales continued to fall slightly. While prices continued to rise on a year-over-year basis, contacts noted that the percentage of houses selling for more than the asking price declined. Housing affordability remained a challenge, and rents remained high. The share of 211 calls [for essential services] that sought assistance for housing have edged higher since the prior period, to 35 percent of total calls – 42 percent of those were for rental assistance. 

Cleveland — Demand for residential construction and real estate remained well below levels experienced earlier in the year. Contacts attributed softer demand to high construction costs and rising interest rates. One homebuilder noted that his firm’s construction starts have outpaced sales over the past couple of months, raising the concern that his backlogs may soon diminish. Contacts anticipated activity would remain slow and did not expect to see any significant improvement in demand in the coming months. 

Richmond — Residential real estate market activity declined moderately this period. Respondents indicated that sales volumes were slightly lower and there was a reduction in buyer traffic. Inventories of homes for sale and days on market increased while home prices have softened. Demand remained strong but it was noted that affordability was an issue as some buyers no longer qualified to purchase a house due to elevated home prices coupled with increasing mortgage rates. Existing new home construction continued but new housing starts were down; some input costs declined this period, like lumber, but on the whole residential construction costs remained elevated. 

Atlanta — Housing markets remained challenged across the district due to rising home prices and interest rates, declining affordability, and inventory shortages. Although some markets experienced a sharp increase in home prices over the past year as housing demand in these regions exceeded supply, overall homebuyer sentiment throughout the district dropped sharply. Mortgage originations and pending home sales declined compared with a year ago, and the share of homes on the market with a reduced asking price rose. Though construction supply-chain issues eased, and cost inflation slowed, homebuilders experienced increased contract cancellations as rising interest rates priced more buyers out of the market. 

Chicago — Construction and real estate activity decreased modestly overall. Residential construction pulled back slightly, and homebuilders expected a further decline in coming months. Residential real estate activity decreased moderately. Contacts noted that the number of offers homes typically received had fallen and that it was taking longer for them to sell. Home-price growth slowed but remained positive. Rents were up modestly. 

St. Louis — Residential real estate demand has slowed significantly since our previous report. Contacts reported that it remains a seller’s market, but the “multiple-offer” market has ended. Prices remain elevated compared with one year ago, and inventories are just beginning to return to pre-pandemic levels. An Arkansas real estate contact noted that, while demand has contracted, it remains above pre-pandemic levels. Demand for rental units has continued to increase since our previous report — especially for single-family housing. Rental rates in all four major district MSAs [metro areas] increased since our previous report. The general outlook of contacts remains negative, with over 80% of contacts in real estate and construction describing their outlook as somewhat or significantly worse than the previous quarter. 

Minneapolis — Residential housing slowed. Recent single- family permitting was lower across the district’s larger markets compared with a year earlier, with higher interest rates reportedly pushing some builders and buyers to pause projects. … Residential real estate activity fell. Closed sales of single-family homes were lower in markets across the district, with many seeing recent year-over-year sales decline by 10% to 30%.

Kansas City — Prices grew rapidly, including housing rental rates. … Housing affordability challenges for both renters and owners grew moderately in both rural and metro areas, particularly for low- and moderate-income (LMI) households. Contacts in several district states pointed to pressures on rental housing prices resulting from increases in investor purchases of local homes. Some investors have been reportedly less willing to accept vouchers or less willing to negotiate rents. Although purchase prices of single-family homes moderated somewhat, contacts reported that rising interest rates have pushed many prospective LMI buyers out of the market. Eviction cases increased in recent months. For example, a record number of eviction cases were filed in the Oklahoma County District Court in July and August. Funds from assistance programs for preventing evictions and foreclosures diminished recently. 

Dallas — Housing-market activity remained weak, particularly at the entry level. Sales were off notably in July but improved in August partly due to a dip in mortgage rates. Home prices were flat to down, and incentives were becoming more widespread. Outlooks were uncertain, with contacts expecting further weakness ahead. Apartment leasing was solid and in line with pre-COVID levels, though momentum has slowed from its 2021 highs. Occupancy was flat to down and rent growth remained elevated but was declining from its earlier feverish pace. … Housing costs have become a primary concern for low-income residents, driven by an insufficient stock of affordable housing, rapid rent hikes, and the winding down of state and federal assistance programs. Evictions have increased, and a rise in first-time homelessness has been seen. 

San Francisco — Residential real estate activity eased further over the reporting period. High mortgage rates and overall economic uncertainty cooled demand for existing and new single-family homes. Conversely, demand for multifamily housing units remained strong and rental rates grew in many regions. A Northern California banker reported a recent increase in financing requests for multifamily construction projects. Despite cooling demand, housing prices remained elevated and inventories strained by historical standards. Homebuilders’ confidence declined further as materials shortages continued to delay existing projects. … Mortgage originations and refinancing activity dipped further as higher interest rates and limited inventories dampened housing activity. 

The post Fed’s Beige Book offers grim news for housing industry appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


The multifamily real estate market seemed almost impenetrable over the past two years. Unless you had millions in dry powder, ready to overpay for a huge apartment complex, there was a low chance you’d be making any money in the multifamily industry. This gave the big buyers an unfair advantage, while smaller investors struggled to put almost anything under contract. The tables have started to turn as interest rates rise, repricing becomes the norm, and multifamily buyers start fleeing the closing table.

It’s now your time to shine, small-scale investors. As large buyers begin to fear a housing market crash, you can swoop up the spoils that could benefit you for years to come. But, before you do so, you’ll need to understand how exactly multifamily investing works. Back again on the show are Andrew Cushman and Matt Faircloth, two multifamily masters in their own rights.

They’ve become real estate veterans after over a decade worth of investing experience. Now, they’re here to share some beginner steps and tips on how you can get into the world of multifamily real estate, regardless of your experience, knowledge, or bank account size. These steps are simplistic at a high level, but doing them correctly could help you beat out the competition for years to come. The only question is, are you ready to start?

David:
This is the BiggerPockets Podcast show 661.

Matt:
Also, finally understand that fear is going to be a real factor for no matter what in the market is. There’s never going to be this no problem market, that there’s nothing in your way and it’s completely clear, and there’s no competition, and the deals are cheap, and the money’s free, and whatnot. That’s utopia real estate. Not going to happen. Don’t wait for utopia real estate to happen. Just find a way to make deals work today and be conservative enough that the deals will work out. If you hold long enough and you do the correct business plan, as Andrew said, it will eventually profit if you hold for the long term.

David:
What’s going on, everyone? This is David Greene, your host of the BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast, coming to you live from Scottsdale, Arizona, where I am checking out investment property and hanging with a couple of my buddies, having a little getaway for the David Greene team and the One Brokerage leadership, and we have an amazing episode for you today. I’ve brought back my good friends, Andrew Cushman and Matt Faircloth, to talk some more multifamily masterclass, wonderfulness and they did not disappoint. This is an episode you will listen to more than once because it is so freaking good.
Basically, we had them on a previous show, and it went so well that everyone said, “Hey, if I want to get started in this right now, what do I need to know?” So we brought back Andrew and Matt to say if you were starting right now from zero, from scratch, with no experience but knowing what you know now, what would you do? They did not disappoint. This is a fantastic episode, where we cover everything from where to find deals, how to underwrite deals, how to choose your market, how to operate the property, how to build a brand, how to communicate with brokers, how to collect acquisition fees, when not to collect them. Everything that you could possibly need to know to get started we cover in today’s episode. You’re going to love this.
Before we bring in Andrew and Matt, a quick word from BiggerPockets for today’s quick tip. Go back and listen to episode 571. This is when I had these two on last, and they gave such a good performance that we brought them back for a followup. So when you get done listening to this, go back and listen to episode 571.
Furthermore, if you’ve got questions that you would like to ask, come to BiggerPockets Conference in October. It’s going to be in San Diego. You should bring all the questions that you can possibly think of and hit us with them. We should be on stage or you could have opportunity to talk to me and the other BiggerPockets personalities. It’s going to be a blast. Make sure you get your tickets and I will see you there. All right. Onto today’s interview.
Andrew, Matt, welcome back to the BiggerPockets Podcast. It’s nice to see you two again, and we have a fun episode planned for the day. How are you, each of you doing?

Matt:
Fantastic, David. Thanks for having us again.

Andrew:
Yeah, I’m excellent. Family’s good. Business is good. Got my espresso, and there’s a swell on the way.

David:
All right. So in today’s show, we are going to be talking about, “If I had to start from zero, if I was just getting started in multifamily today, what would I do?” which is really cool because we’re hitting the point of how would you get started, but it’s coming from the perspective of very experienced investors with a whole bunch of knowledge in their brain. It’s like that idea where people say, “Would you rather know what you know now or have to go back to where you were in high school?” and you’re like, “I want to know what I know now when I was in high school,” but that’s not ever the option. You can’t do both, but in today’s episode, it’s like you can.
So this is going to be being in high school and having a future person show up at your high school, step out of their spaceship and say, “Here’s everything that you should do to become rich and multifamily.” So let’s start with you, Matt. Step one, what’s the first thing that you would do if you were starting from zero?

Matt:
I’m sorry. I’m still fantasizing on talking to my younger self in high school, David, but yeah, but getting beyond that, what I would start with is I think too many people start with doing a deal. I think those that are just getting started with multifamily or real estate investing in general, they’re out there just trying to find a deal, “Okay. I just want to get going. Let me go and evaluate a duplex.” To be honest, the Matt that started investing in real estate 17 years ago did that. I looked at a land deal, that I looked at a single family home, that I looked at whatever come across my plate. I think that what I would do if Matt were to start again today would be to evaluate my goals, my skills, what do I bring to the table, what am I great at and how can I manifest those greatnesses through real estate, what unfair advantages do I have over the other person that’s starting as well in this business.
So I would take personal inventory and also take a realistic goal set. I mean, listen, I get it. We all want to make a billion dollars next week. I got it, but set realistic, achievable goals for what you can really tackle and maybe a deal is a good goal for the first year, a deal, maybe two, but set those goals and take personal inventory. That’s what I recommend and that’s what I would do if I were starting again.

David:
I love that. That’s something I’ve noticed just this pattern in real estate investing in general, that whenever I have something of value today, a lot of equity in a property, really good cash flow in a property, options to do a cash out refinance or something, it’s almost always from a decision I made somewhere between three to five years ago. That’s just the way it works. What everything I’m buying right now will benefit future David in five years tremendously. It’s like every time I buy a house I’m just loving future me. It’s not going to do a ton for me right off the bat, but it will later.
I think that’s a tough thing to swallow because who wants to work off of a five-year timeframe when you’re being told, “Get into real estate investing. It’s going to change your life,” and you’re like, “Oh, I want to lose weight right now,” type of thing, but that’s not really how the asset class is designed. What about you, Andrew? Do you agree with that point, and then is that the same thing that you would do if you were starting off?

Andrew:
Yeah, I do, and actually, I got a couple things to add to that. So David, what you were saying, I call that current self and future self, right? If I’ve got something amazing from Cheesecake Factory and I’m like, “Hey, I could save half of this for tomorrow,” I’m like, “you know what? Future self is going to be really happy with me if I do that for a number of reasons.” So I actually frame a lot of things exactly how you just said, current self and future self. Many times, it might not feel great for current self, but future self is going to look back and thank you, right?
So I do frame things a lot in that way, and then I also would step back and say, “Okay. If I were starting today, there’s a piece of advice out there that probably 99.873% of BiggerPockets pockets listeners and can recite, and that’s Warren Buffet says, “Buy when everybody else is fearful and sell when everybody else is greedy,” right?
So guess what? Right now, people are getting really fearful, but the problem with that advice is everybody can recite it but very few people can actually do it because what we do is we confuse fear with reasons, “Oh, well interest rates might be doing this and I don’t know what prices are going to do,” blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, and those are rational justifications and those are true things, but that’s also what makes it so that no one can actually put that advice into work.
So what you have to do, if I was starting today and it is a much more scary environment than if I was starting five years ago, there’s no denying that or much more uncertain, I should say, is not say, “Well, I’m just going to wait a couple years and see how it shakes out,” because then you’re going to miss everything, but to buy when other people are fearful, you just have to adapt the strategy to the market and pick the right strategies and look towards, “All right. Are prices going to be down 10% a year from now?” Maybe.
None of us really knows, but if I’m looking at future self, my future benefits looking five, seven, 10 years down the road, if I pick the right asset in the right market, I’m going to benefit when I get there, and probably even in the interim. Therefore, if I focus on that and learn to focus on that with that mindset, then that gives you the ability to buy when others are fearful.
I think that’s the first step right now with the current is to tune out the market and the noise, address the fact that, yes, there are some real uncertainties, but factor those things in and move forward. So that’s the first thing I would do in terms of mindset.
Then Matt mentioned goals and deciding who you’re going to be. I would decide, “Okay. Am I going to build the stack method and am I going to go for a fourplex and then go to a 10 and then go to a 20 and do this with just my own money and build a portfolio that I can manage and live off of or am I going to try to build a business? Am I going to try to get to 2,000 units? Am I going to try to hire people? Am I going to syndicate?” Figure out what the end goal is there and then start working backwards.

Matt:
Just to add onto that, and I think that we could expand on that further, but that, though, you and I took two different paths, Andrew. We’ve gotten to know each other fairly well. I was that guy buying a single family home, duplex, whatever, and scaled up through the space, which is certainly one way to get started because some would say a four-family, a five-family, a 10-family, whatever, that’s still multifamily. It doesn’t have to be 100 units to be multifamily. You can scale that way or as you said, you can go and swing for the fences and maybe join somebody else’s team or become a part of a larger conglomerate that’s taking down bigger deals, but there’s no right answer. They’re both ways to get in and ways to get going.
Start small. People that are starting small I just tell them, “Listen, a good goal is to double your portfolio every time you do a deal. Just double up, double up, double up, double up, and you’ll grow real fast that way or go and take down bigger deals and maybe don’t get the lion’s share in the beginning, but you’ll get at least a foot in and you can say you were part of a transaction that took down 100 unit, 200 unit multifamily, and slowly scale and build your own team with the lessons you learned there.”

David:
Couple things that came to mind when you were talking there, Andrew, is the first is the Batman’s story, oddly enough. So if you read the comic books of Batman, they’re a little different than the movies, but Batman’s motivation was he was very afraid when he was young and bats were his phobia. He got afraid of them. So rather than letting that fear control him, he said, “I want to harness this and make my enemies as afraid of me as I was of bats,” and that’s why he took on this identity of Batman. In the comic books, he was much more known for using terror tactics. They weren’t just he fights better and he has cool gadgets. He would hit you in the darkness. He would make noises that would make you afraid. He wanted the criminals to be afraid. That speaks to the power of harnessing fear.
As you were talking I thought, “We always ask people what sets apart the successful investors from those that give up, fail or never get started.” I think what no one said but is really good is your ability to harness fear because opportunities only come when everyone else is scared, at least the best opportunities come in that point, right? If you can’t learn to operate in fear, you’re probably never going to make a lot of traction.
The best deals I’ve ever bought were when I first got started, 2009, ’10, ’11. Hindsight, everybody says, “I wish I could go back to that point.” No, you don’t, man. Nobody was buying houses at that point. Everyone was calling me a fool. I think the other time is right now. I’ve ramped up and I bought a lot and I’m getting a lot of backlash, “You’re buying too early, you needed to wait. We have a huge recession coming. You shouldn’t be buying.” Who knows? They may be right, but very well also maybe that because I bought now, the market’s going to run up when interest rates come back down, and the economy starts to do better, and you look really good, but either way, you got to be able to operate in that spirit of uncertainty because if you think about when everything is best, when the deal is the most ideal, if everybody in the market felt good, it would be like Black Friday.
That’s when the TV or the PlayStation or whatever is at the very best price it’s ever going to be, but how many people actually get that amazing big screen TV or that PlayStation when they’re lined up with every other psycho on Black Friday? Right? Your odds of landing it are so small when you’re in the big pool of people that are rushing in. So I think that’s such good advice for someone who’s getting started is understand you’re going to be afraid. It’s normal to be afraid, and you’ve got to harness that fear rather than wait for it to be gone because if you wait, you’re going to find yourself lined up on Black Friday with a huge mob of people around you and probably getting stepped on.

Andrew:
So the second point is once I’ve got my mindset figured out, and once I’ve decided what my end goal is, “Am I buying small properties? Am I buying big properties? Is it a business? Is it my own portfolio?” is picking a market. So the first thing I would do, and I’ve read this, is go read your book, Long Distance Real Estate Investing. It is geared towards single family, but the same principles apply to multifamily. So I’d read that book and be like, “Okay. Cool. I can invest anywhere long distance. Let’s pick a state. Oh, crap, there’s 50 of them. Now what?” There’s a lot to choose from.”
So what I would do is I would go to the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies website, and there is a beautiful map on there that shows migration trends by county across the entire United States, both net and then inbound. It color codes it, and you can see all of the counties in the US that have the strongest population growth. They’re the darkest blue. I would go select markets that are in that dark blue color because the number one positive fundamental for multifamily, the strongest tailwind, which, David, as you’ve recently clarified, the tailwind is the one that pushes you forward and helps you out, right? The strongest tailwind is population growth, people moving to an area. That ensures your multifamily success almost more than anything else.
So I would go to that website and pick markets that are blue and start there and then narrow down and say, “Well, okay. Hey, the Florida Panhandle is dark blue. I like visiting the beaches there. All right. Well, let’s check that out,” right? Florida, as everyone knows, no income tax, very business-friendly. So you start narrowing it down from there.
I joked about visiting the beaches, but again, what are your goals? How easy is it to get there? So people ask me all the time, “Andrew, how do you invest in the southeast and live in California?” There are five direct flights a day to Atlanta from Southern California. It’s a four and a half hour nonstop flight. If something pops up urgent, I can literally be there the next day, no problem, even though it’s a couple thousand miles away.
So that’s the next thing I would do is pick that market or multiple markets because you want to get it down to a short list that you’re probably going to eliminate a few from, and then start asking those questions. Is it easy to get to? Is one of those markets a market that you already know really well? So for example, maybe you used to live in Dallas and now you live in Washington State, and Dallas shows up as one of those high potential markets when you look at that map. Well, that’s another positive factor for maybe why you should pick Dallas. You already know the market or maybe you’ve got an aunt or a cousin or family members that still live there and they can be your initial work-for-free boots on the ground.
So those are the things that I would do to pick a market. Again, that dovetails with what my goals are. If I’m just trying to build up 20 units and I can drive to them once a week and check on them, then I’m probably going to be in my own backyard, but if I’m looking to build a larger portfolio and just really go where the returns are, those are the first few things that I would do. Then once I’ve narrowed that down to maybe a short list of three or four larger metros, I’d really start diving into what are the economic drivers. Are they things that are favored going forward or things that might be on the decline going forward?
Also, I would be looking for economic diversity. A very, one newbie trap to watch out for is you’ll see towns that have great economic numbers, but then you find out it’s because one plant got built there three years ago and it doubled the population and doubled the workforce, but guess what? If that plant shuts down or scales back down, then all of a sudden you’re going in the other direction. So you want to have a diverse workforce.
I would look for counties and cities that have high education, medical facilities, transportation, logistics, tech. All of those things that are growing are favored by the current political environment like anything green energy. We just got a whole another slew of tax benefits for that kind of stuff. Pick markets that check all those boxes and then move on to the next steps. Matt, I know you probably have a few other things to add to that, so I’ll pause and hand off to you.

Matt:
You said all the good things already, Andrew.

Andrew:
Oh, I did. Well, there you go.

Matt:
No, no, no. Everything Andrew said, amazing. Underscore a few things that he said that I want to just highlight for our standards when we look at markets. Yes, population, but as Andrew also said, population, that’s a good leading indicator, but go to why. People move to markets. Used to be just for jobs, right? Now, some people can work remote. A lot of blue collar middle income folks can’t work remote, but there’s some folks that can. So lifestyle becomes a factor, right?
So let’s say, for example, I’ll pick market. Asheville, North Carolina is a fun place to live. There is hiking. There’s all kinds of beer breweries, and all kinds of fun. Now, maybe prior, you moved to Asheville because there was a job there, but now, “Well, I can work 50% remote so I’m going to go and pick a job that allows me to work from home so I can enjoy the lifestyle that a certain city like Asheville,” or pick any number of cities that have a good lifestyle benefit and also a growing economy may have as well. So that becomes a factor too.
For us, job diversity, as you said, certainly not one plant, but we also look at the industries that are driving a city. So if there is a city that you like, but it’s driven by 50% the oil and gas industry or driven by 50% auto, well, let’s look what happened to Detroit that was driven a ton by the automotive industry. Once that industry dries up or starts to move or relocate to other places, that really affects that town. So for my company, for the DeRosa Group, we won’t invest in a city if there is more than 20% of that economy driven by a certain industry because if a recession hits, it’s not going to hit everything across the board. It’s going to hit certain industries more than others.
I don’t have a crystal ball, so I can’t predict what any recession would look like. I can take a guess, but if I invest in a city that is economically diverse, the recession’s certainly not going to affect that. Every industry, the same. Might affect some more than others, and even hit that city a little bit more than others, but there’s other industries that won’t be hit as hard, and if that market’s diverse, then it’s certainly going to get blended out a little bit better.

David:
All right. Andrew, to follow up to what Matt just said, what is the biggest mistake people should look out for when they’re choosing their market?

Andrew:
The biggest mistake to watch out for, and it’s really, really common, and candidly, I made this myself when I started out, so everybody listening, please don’t make the same mistake I made. Do not pick a market because it’s cheap. It is often very cheap for a very good reason. Again, I’ve said this before, I’d probably get a T-shirt now, but the grass is greenest over the septic tank. When I look back over the decade plus of doing this, the best returns and with the least amount of headache were in the mid price range, the C plus to A minus, not the stuff where, “Well, I can buy this 1975 property in Podunk, Iowa for 30,000 a door. Why would I go pay 130 a door outside of Atlanta for the property in the same age?” Well, because in Atlanta, you’ve got a huge diverse job market. You’ve got population growth. You’ve got much higher rent. There’s all kinds of reasons. So don’t be seduced by the siren call of cheap markets.

Matt:
Just to back you up there, Andrew. It’s so well-said because you got to realize, unless you really are the only buyer for a market, if you whisper to a seller’s ear, “Hey, I want to buy your property.” “Okay. Great. Let’s work it out,” and there’s no other competition, then yeah, you set your price, but if there are multiple buyers for any property or if it’s a property on a free market, the market’s going to determine the price. If a property is only selling for 30K a door, that means that is the absolute most that that seller could get for that property. Some people view it as an opportunity, and unless you have insider information like the winds of change are coming through that market and that property’s going to be the next Hoboken, New Jersey or the next Savannah, Georgia or the next something amazing or the next Austin, Texas, then you’re really gambling probably with other people’s money, and that’s not a good thing to do.
So I agree with you that there is a reason why cheap properties are cheap. You can’t be enamored by, “Oh, the price is low.” Well, likely, the rents are going to be low. The economy’s going to be weak. Make the list of the reasons why that property is low priced.
I will just agree with you, and also, I’ll add one more factor on the biggest mistake people make on properties, and that is they go and start making offers too soon without building their backstory of why the market’s amazing because if you’ve never heard of never been to, not sure too much about Albuquerque, New Mexico, but you start bidding on properties there and you get so cursed to land a deal, then you got to go tell your investors why Albuquerque, New Mexico is amazing. If you don’t have that data and you don’t have a property manager lined up, and you don’t have who your closing attorney’s going to be, and have the data in place on how you’re going to build a business plan around a deal, going in early and making offers before you’ve really established your presence and build your foundation is I think yet another, and it’s up there with buying properties because they’re cheap, that’s yet another mistake, David.

David:
All right. Moving on. Let’s say that someone is ready to start looking at properties, and thank you, Matt, for mentioning there that writing offers too early is a pretty big mistake. I would agree with that. Usually, when you first get into a market or at least when I do, the first several buyers are usually not great. Usually with hindsight, they end up being just an average. It wasn’t usually terrible, but even doing my best, I end up with a mediocre deal, but then after you learn the market a little bit, that’s when the good deals start to come.
So I would say go in light. For the first one that you’re going to do, you don’t want to spend all your money. You don’t want to go in super huge. You don’t want to have this huge big vision. The first deal, just go in knowing, “I’m putting the boat in the water and I’m waiting to see where the leaks come, but they’re going to be somewhere so I’m not going to start with a battleship.”
What would you say? Andrew, you started last time, so Matt, we’ll start with you first on this one. When you’re ready to start looking at properties, what would you be doing if you’re starting today from zero?

Matt:
I would go and buy myself an airplane ticket and go to that market and actually physically go look at the market. I cannot tell you, David, how many people I’ve met that are like, “I can’t seem to get a deal and here’s the market that I picked. I’m looking at all these opportunities and nothing just seems to add up.”
I said, “Well, how many times you’ve physically been to the market?”
“Oh, I’ve never been there.”
I mean, get it. It’s like, “Well, how do you know what the good neighborhood’s bad where you could get duped by everybody? You don’t even know what the real opportunities are, where the construction’s happening, where development’s happening.”
So go to the market. Brokers are going to take you way more seriously if you look them dead in the eye and buy them a cup of coffee or whatever and talk about what your goals are, talk about what your plans are, what your resources are, what you can bring. They’re going to remember you as opposed to just somebody that sent them an email saying, “Hey, send me deals.”
So I would physically go to the market as my first move. Once I feel like I’m qualified to start making offers and I’ve picked the market and I’ve done my research and built my backstory, then I would go to the market and do tons of homework, lots of window shopping, and maybe tour some apartment buildings. Do what they call a secret shop, where you just go and show up and maybe pretend like you want to move there like, “I’d love to look at a two-bedroom apartment for me and my wife,” or whatever or maybe don’t. Maybe just tell them that you’re interested in investing there and they’ll probably show you around anyway. So do everything you can to get to know that market like the back of your hand.

Andrew:
Yeah. I 100% agree with that. There’s so many good reasons to do that. Then I would also add in that you hear people, “Oh, how’s it going?”
“Oh, I can’t find a deal.”
“Well, how many have you looked at?”
“Three.”
“Okay.”
So go into it with the mindset of looking at deals as like dating. You’re going to have lots and lots and lots that don’t work out, but those ones that don’t work out help you better realize and appreciate the one that really does, right? All the dating apps came out after I got married, so I can’t keep straight. If you swipe left or right is good. I think swiping left is bad, but you’re going to want to swipe left on probably a thousand deals before you swipe right on one because the majority of them aren’t going to work, but the more you look at that don’t work, the better you’re going to spot the one that does.
So go into it with the mindset of, “I am analyzing this deal to educate myself on the market, to educate myself on the state of operations, to give myself material to have better conversations with brokers, and if I get lucky, I might get a deal out of this.” That’s the approach to have is you’re looking at deals with those other things as your main goals because, really, you can’t directly control whether or not you’re going to win a deal, but you can control your approach to it and how many that you look at. Eventually, you will get the one that works.
So how would I actually go out and find those deals? I would go look at the MLS for my chosen market. I would go to a website called Crexi, C-R-E-X-I. Everyone’s heard of LoopNet. Go there. Really, you’re not looking for hot deals on those places. You’re looking for listings so you can start figure out who to call to start relationships. Then also, go to the big broker websites and sign up for their email blast for those markets, right? Berkadia, Cushman & Wakefield, CBRE, Marcus & Millichap, Colliers. Go join their mailing list so that you get everything that they process in that market. Again, it’s going to be the listed stuff, but you’re doing that to learn the market and figure out who to start relationships with.
Another thing I would do is those big brokerage houses I just mentioned are awesome, but in my experience, many of our best deals come from the smaller, local, and regional brokers, the ones who only cover one market. Those guys might not have the volume of a Cushman & Wakefield or Marcus & Millichap, but they do tend to dig up really good deals, and on the flip side, they may not have the volume, but they’re probably also not sending that deal to a mailing list of 50,000 investors.
So you build a relationship and track record with a local or regional broker. That can have a lot of benefits. So I highly recommend figuring out who they are, and you’re going to do that just by keeping … Matt, you said go to the market, right? That’s how you find out who those people are. You’re not going to see them on headlines on Biz Now or the Atlanta Chronicle or whatever. You’re going to have to talk to people and mingle, and that’s how you find those out, and those are some of the most valuable sources.
Then like I mentioned, call and talk to those brokers. When you’re looking at those thousand bad deals, don’t say, “Oh, this doesn’t work, left. Oh, this doesn’t work, left.” No. Call the broker and say, “Hey, thanks for sending this to me. I took a look at it. It looks like a great asset and a great market, but unfortunately, it doesn’t work for me because it’s in a flood zone,” or “The crime rate was too high,” or whatever that reason is that shows that you’re a legitimate buyer who took the time to look at it and give them feedback.
The number one way to annoy brokers is to just not respond and not call them back. Call them and tell them no. They appreciate that because now they know they don’t have to follow up with you. So if I was starting off today, I would make a very strong point to always, especially with the little things, if I say I’m going to do something, do it. If I say, “Hey, thanks for sending this deal. I’ll get back to you in two days,” I’ll get back to them in two days.
So in regards of screening those properties like, “Okay. Andrew, great. I look at these thousand deals. What do I do?” We cover that in super detail on I think it was episode 279, where we went through that whole screening process. So I’d go re-listen to that, but you’re going to check for parameters like the population growth and crime and flood zones and all of those kind of things, but that’s what I would do in terms of looking at properties and finding deals.

Matt:
David, just to underscore something Andrew said, somebody taught me a mantra a while ago that if you take a broker seriously, they will return the favor. Yeah. Although their deal may be double the price on what you can pay for it, although it’s in the worst part of town with lots of crime and it’s 10 feet under the flood plain level and everything like that, take it seriously. Give them feedback. Don’t throw rocks at it, “Oh, it’s overpriced. Send me an off-the-market deal.” No, because it’s their livelihood. I think that people forget that that this broker is feeding their family on that deal and they hope that somebody will buy it, and they’re not trying to just slip somebody a bad deal. They’re trying to market a deal that’s on their plate that they’re trying to push. It is what it is. It’s their livelihood too. If you show them respect, they’ll do the same.

David:
Well, the brokers in multifamily are usually representing the sellers. It’s not like residential where you have your own agent who represents your interest and the seller has their own. So you have to realize they’re being paid from proceeds that come from the seller. They have a relationship with the seller first. It’s not necessarily a situation where they’re supposed to be advocating for you. Just if they’re mismarketing a property, we would call it mismarketing from the buyer side, but from a seller side is they would say that they are cleverly marketing a property, right? They’re trying to get as much money as they can and actually get it sold.
So that’s why we tell people you’ve got to understand due diligence, especially if you’re moving into the multifamily space because you don’t have that hand holder. You don’t have that agent that theoretically is going to be looking out for you nearly as much. They’re expecting you to know what you’re doing and to be doing your own due diligence. It’s a different way of doing real estate. So it’s a waste of time to get angry and say, “Oh, this trailing 12, it’s crap,” or “Oh, this proforma is garbage.” Just expect it’s going to be garbage because the seller is the one paying them, not you. The seller doesn’t think it’s garbage. The seller thinks it’s amazing. They’re like, “Wow. This is clever accounting. This is why I want you to be selling my house,” right? To a buyer, we think it’s unethical.

Matt:
Put everything below the line.

David:
That’s exactly right.

Matt:
Just rent real estate taxes. Those are all of my income and expenses. That’s it. Now, I don’t expect much from brokers aside from, but I still treat them with respect, but you still got to run your own numbers and do your own analysis and do your own due diligence, and a lot of brokers can be very kind.

David:
They’re the gatekeeper. You got to treat them with respect.

Matt:
Yeah, but a lot of brokers can be kind to you and you can end up getting duped and think that they represent you because they act like they do, but they actually don’t. Don’t forget. They actually represent, really, they represent the deal. They want the deal to close. Their primary objective is to get the deal to closing above all else.

Andrew:
It’s also a bit of garbage in, garbage out, right? A lot of times the brokers can’t get a straight story from the owner or the seller, and they’re doing everything they can to just get an honest listing, and not all sellers are forthright even with their own brokers.

David:
Okay. Moving on. When it comes to building your team, Andrew, we’ll start here with you, what is something that you would be doing right now starting at year zero?

Andrew:
So what I would be doing right now is the exact same thing I did 10 or 12 years ago is I went through the process that we just described. I picked Atlanta, and I would still pick Atlanta today, by the way. It’s just everything is even more true now than it was back then. So all right, I’ve picked Atlanta. I’m looking at deals. Well, how am I going to manage these things? How am I going to get loans on them? So those are the next two pieces of the team that I’d be working on or the two pieces of the business that I’ll be working on simultaneously with looking deals. If you do it right, it’s very synergistic.
So every time I’m looking at a deal, let’s say I just picked Atlanta and I’m going all those websites, I’m starting to call brokers, but in the context here is I’m going to use third-party management, right? So Matt, if you want to talk more about self-managing, please jump in. That’s just a business choice. Again, it goes back to what your goals are. For me, it’s third-party management.
So I’ve picked Atlanta, and now I’m like, “Okay. I got to figure out who’s going to manage these things.” When you’re calling the brokers and you’re giving them feedback on the deals that you’re looking at, if it’s a deal where there’s at least some potential, and you’re ending the conversation with, “All right. Let me go back and do some more underwriting. I’ll come back to you,” or maybe you’re getting to the point finally, “Hey, I’m going to put in an LOI.” The question that you want to ask is if you were broker, if you were going to buy this yourself, who are the top two or three people you would hire to manage it for you? You write those companies in those names down.
Then at the same time you say, “Hey, Mr. Broker, who is your favorite loan officer or lender to work with in this space?” Add those people to your list. Over a pretty short period of time, you built a substantive list of recommendations and referrals for management and lenders. Those are going to be your two key because the money is made in operations, right? So your manager is an absolute key player in the success of your business, and if you don’t have a lender that you can rely on to close, you’re never going to get in the business. So those are, to me, the two most important pieces of the team and you build that from referrals.
So what I did, and again, what exactly what I would do again today, I would build that list and then I would take that list, I would go research on the internet, what is the reputation of these property managers and these lenders? Are there stories of the lender backing out the last minute? Do all the properties managed by this property management company have zero star reviews? All those kind of things. Narrow it down, then do phone interviews with them, and then getting back to, Matt, what you started with, when I narrowed that list down to two or three, I go to the market and have lunch or dinner with these people and do an extended casual interview and then I pick one.
That process is what has led for us, we found all of our lenders that way, referrals and narrowing it down, and then the property management company that today manages our entire portfolio is the first one we ever picked, and they’ve worked out phenomenally well because we took the time to go through that rather lengthy process to build the list, narrow it down, in-person interviews, and they’ve been an amazing partner. So that is exactly what I would do today to figure out who’s going to manage for me and who’s going to lend for me. I would do a similar process, maybe not quite as thorough, but a similar process for your insurance broker, contractor attorneys, contractors, all those kind of things, and all those people.

Matt:
Yeah. I think property managers are the key to any real estate asset. Property manager can make a mediocre deal really good by running it super efficiently and they can also make a really good deal mediocre worse by taking your business plan and disregarding it and wrapping it around a tree and completely screwing everything up. I’ve seen both, right? So I completely agree with you there.
A few notes on self-management, right? Anybody listening to this that has a goal set for going out and buying anything north of say 30 units should not consider self-managing. If you’re going to start really small, like I said before, double up every time you do a deal. Well, you could start that equation at four units and maybe that’s a house stack that you live in, and then you do four, then you do eight, then you do 16, then you scale your team as you grow into larger assets.
At DeRosa Group, we got up to about 115 units managing ourselves, and then we get out of that. We get out of self-managing because we saw where we were growing as a company. We’re growing into larger and larger assets. I knew that self-management was not something that was going to be able to keep up with the growth of our acquisitions. So we let it go.
That said, self-managing taught me so much as a landlord, as a property owner, right? So I learned just the human side of the business. I learned interacting with people, strategies for collecting rent, leasing strategies, management strategies, how to handle maintenance, and how to handle preventative maintenance, not just wait for the tenant to call and say, “Hey, there’s a bunch of water coming from the ceiling in my kitchen,” how to set those preventative maintenance things up. I still use those lessons in the larger multifamily world that we’re in now.
So if there is a plan in the listener’s goals to start small, I highly recommend self-managing in the beginning so you can learn some of the ropes as you scale up, but plan to hand those reigns over to somebody else eventually, but there’s no better classroom than self-management in the beginning on small stuff.

Andrew:
Well said, sir. It’s almost like you’ve done this before.

Matt:
I know. It’s almost like I’ve got the battle scars to show you and all the lessons I could teach you, not you, but just that I’ve learned that this business has taught me really in self-management.

David:
That’s why we have you two here to talk about what people need to know if they’re starting from zero. I didn’t ask you guys this earlier, but I wanted to circle back to it briefly before we move on if you could give me an answer. When it comes to looking for deals, how much time would you put into every individual deal that crosses your plate with analyzing it if you were starting with the knowledge you have now at zero?

Matt:
17 hours. No, just kidding. So 17 hours per deal and no less.

David:
I noticed that new investors-

Matt:
No, no, no, no, no. I don’t need it. It was an opportunity for a cheesy joke and I walked through it. So what we do is we do a phase one and phase two analysis. So you got to determine some go/no go points for a deal. Obviously, if it’s in the market that I want to be in, if it’s in the neighborhood of the city that I want to be in, if it checks all the location boxes and checks the deal size boxes, then we do a phase one analysis that has to do with crime stats, that has to do with comparison of the rents collected on site currently versus what we believe or know the market to be.
We do a Google Street view drive-by just to make sure that there’s not a methadone clinic right across the street. We do just things … You know what it is? Andrew, I’m sure you’ll agree with me on this one. I look for something that can be an absolute no automatically. I know flood zone is a no for you, right, Andrew? So the flood search would be one of Andrew’s phase ones and that. So you want to poke a hole in the deal. I want to get the deal to a no, and if I can’t get it to a no through any of those things, then it goes to phase two, which we spent a lot more time on it, but that phase one analysis can take anywhere between 30 minutes to an hour at the most.

Andrew:
Yep. We’re not too different. So that screening process that we talked about previously, that’s a 15-minute deal. That’s checking your parameters, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, and just like Matt said, we’re looking for the reason, a hard reason to say no. If it passes screening and it goes to that phase one quick and dirty underwriting, that was episode 571, I think, we went through that in real detail, that’s about 45 minutes. Then of course, if it passes that, now you’re going to dive in deep. If it doesn’t pass that, you’re done with it.
The one caveat I would say is if you have the luxury of more time and your true goal is just to really learn the market, then you might want to spend more time diving in deeper just for that purpose, but if you’re trying to swipe left on that first thousand deals, 15 minutes to screen it, 45 to do a quick underwriting.

David:
I love your point with that.

Matt:
Well, let me proof in the pudding. Andrew, how many deals does your company underwrite last year in 2021, off the cuff?

Andrew:
Oh, five or six hundred, I think.

Matt:
Yeah. It’s around the same with us, right? So if I were to spend really 17 hours on 500, I’d still be underwriting 2021 deals right now, right? So there needs to be a method to get a lot of these deals to nos because not every deal is going to work in that. So the two-tiered approach I think is necessary because there’s just certain criteria you have that are just not going to get met. So it’s an easy way to disqualify it.

David:
I love the point that the value in doing it when you’re new is you’re learning from doing it, but you hit a point where you are no longer learning by just doing whatever activity it is in your business. If you’re a real estate agent, sometimes going on a listing employment with a not very motivated seller is good because you get practice giving your listing presentation and you get feedback from someone and you learn to read people, but once you’ve got that, stop going on appointments when the person’s not motivated. You’re looking for motivation. So that’s a very good point. If you were starting from scratch, analyzing a deal can have some value for you because stuff pops up you might not have learned or you get better at it.
Everything in life is a skill. The more deals you analyze, the better you become at analyzing and the faster you can do it, but once you’ve got that skill down, find nos. That was also a great point that you made, Matt. You’re looking for a no. That’s a hard no, and that’s where you start, “Let’s get rid of all of that. “I couldn’t find anything wrong with it. Okay. I guess I got to dive a little deeper. Let’s go into a little more granular detail. Shoot. I still couldn’t find anything wrong with it. Now I got to start to get excited about this.
Let’s go into the third step. So Andrew, do you remember what episode we did where we actually walked people through the process that we have when we’re evaluating multifamily property, the three-step or-

Andrew:
Yeah. It was I said the quick analysis, the 15-minute analysis, that was I think 279, and then the quick and dirty 45-minute underwriting was 571. Then I don’t recall what the episode was where we went deeper into it.

David:
So check out those if you want to see exactly. You start with what we call the big rocks and then you scale down. When you get to the sand, if you still can’t find anything wrong with that deal, that’s where it’s time to start moving forward. Okay. Another part of running a successful business is building your brand. So I think, Andrew, you’re up first on this one. What are some things that you would keep in mind if you were starting over with building your brand?

Andrew:
So I’m ancient. I started this before all the social media stuff, and Matt is more of the expert on that and literally wrote the book on raising money, but for building a brand, I would say the key things, one of the most important things that a lot of people don’t consider when they think about building a brand, a lot of people think brand is, “Okay. What’s my logo going to be? My colors got to match, I got to wear the same shirt on every podcast,” all that kind of stuff, right? No. Part of your brand is how you communicate and being consistent with that.
If you’re going to have investors, are you going to give them monthly reports, quarterly reports? What kind of data are you going to give them? How are you going to do that? Part of your brand is, are you aggressive? Are you conservative? How reliable are you in those little things? Brand is not just Instagram and Facebook. Brand is your reputation in the market with the brokers, your reputation in the market with the lenders.
So if I was starting off and I’m like, “Okay. I’m going to build my brand,” I want part of my brand to be when people think, “Okay. Hey, that Andrew guy, he’s new, but, man, you know what? Every time he says he is going to call me, he does, and he gives me great feedback, and he just seems like a reliable guy. I’m going to show him this deal.” So I think of brand in terms of those things. That’s the base. Then Matt, you’re the expert on how to actually get that out there to the public.

Matt:
Yeah. Oh, thank you. Again, whether you’re going to use social media or any of those kinds of ways, you can’t say, “Oh, I’m not going to use social media. I’ve already got all my investors lined up so I don’t need social media.” That doesn’t mean you don’t need a brand because as Andrew said, a brand is really how the market views you, and it’s the things the market can expect from you, and that market also means those that you do business with. So it’s important to sit down and think about, “Well, what do I want the market to rely on me for? What are the things that we stand for as a company?” If you choose to use social media, you don’t have to say, “Hey, my brand means this, and the things I stand for are these things.” Just tell them without telling them. Tell them as a part of your story, continue to talk.
One of the things that the DeRosa Group stands for is transparency. So we put that out regularly in our YouTube. I’ll tell any investor directly what’s going on. We put the cameras on inside of apartments that have been completely destroyed by tenants and stuff like that. So we talk about the good, the bad, and the ugly of this business and that’s transparency. So that is something that you have to define on what it is you want to stand for in building your brand.
Then you got to stay consistent. So if you decide, “I’m going to put this out on Twitter or put Instagram posts out to build my brand or to build the eyeballs that are watching for me,” decide what you want to commit to on posts on social or articles you’re going to write for third-party sites or posts you’re going to do on BiggerPockets, whatever it is, and then stick to it.
So pick your message that you’re going to stick to your brand and then make a commitment on the regular times you’re going to release those to whatever mediums that there are, and do it over and over and over and over and over and over and over again. I committed to myself years ago that I would do two YouTube videos a week, and I haven’t stopped doing that for nine years since we started our YouTube channel. It’s just religion. We just do it two times a week all the time. You can add other social media feeds onto that. So that’s how you build a brand.
Whether you have a deal, and by the way, and the last thing, don’t wait to post on social about what you’re doing until you have a deal. That’s the biggest mistake I see. You see people post a deal and it’s like, “Man, I haven’t heard from you in four months. Now all of a sudden you’re posting all over social media now that you have a deal.” I think that people see through that. I think that if you’re constantly wanting to be seen in your market as the one that knows a lot about real estate investing, then you should be posting whether you have a deal or not, writing articles, putting out concepts. Don’t just wait till you have an opportunity to put it out because people are going to see that. They’re going to see that that’s really just trying to sell and are all sizzle no steak.

David:
Matt, when it comes to OPM, what’s something that you would definitely keep in mind starting from zero?

Matt:
Finding the OPM before you got the deal, right? Yet again, David, the biggest mistake that people make, and that’s social media post, but also emailing and making phone calls to prospective equity that may want to passively invest in your deal. The mistake they make is putting that deal out there to their base once they’ve got a deal instead engaging their base well ahead of the time that they have the deal and say, “Hey, let’s talk about real estate investing. Let’s talk about what capacity you may have,” and really formulating what equity capacity their database of potential investors may have before they go look at the opportunity. So many people I see wait till the deal comes in, then they start soliciting equity. So the biggest tip for OPM is have those conversations. As soon as you pick a market, you should be talking to equity on top of that.

Andrew:
Yeah. Matt’s right. I mean, the minute you decide you’re going to go into this business, start telling people about it and start finding out who might be interested in your next deal. Also, try to raise money from pessimists because they don’t expect it back. That’s definitely helped. No. The reality, I just, but the truth of it is underpromise and overdeliver. You may not get a few people who invest in your deal if you say, “Hey, mine’s a 14% return,” and they’re like, “Well, all these other emails I got say 20% return.” If you think it’s going to be 16%, give yourself a high probability of exceeding expectations and say, “You know what? We think this is a super solid 14,” and know that you got an 80% chance of beating that. So underpromise, overdeliver.
Matt, you touched on this earlier. No matter what, be transparent. If a deal’s going bad, tell your investors about what’s going bad and what your plan is to address it and how it might affect them. Do not hide anything. Be fully transparent.
Then the third thing is whatever you do, never go silent. If you go silent, everybody will assume, often correctly, that there’s not a good reason for that. So even if it’s, “Man, I’m just so busy. I got all these great deals. They’re all crushing it. All my investors are making way more than we told them. I’m just too busy to write the report this quarter.” Absolutely not. Never ever miss your communication. Matt, you said you’ve done your YouTube twice a week for nine years straight. That’s how if I was getting started I would approach my investor communications.
You want your investors to be like, “Oh, it’s the 26th of the month. I’ll be getting my updates today because I have for the last seven years straight.” So those are the things I would do. I would make sure that I underpromise so that I have a high probability of overdelivering, and I would be absolutely transparent, and then be consistent and reliable and never ever, ever go dark or go quiet.

David:
Awesome. Okay. What about long term planning? If you guys were starting over from scratch, what would you keep in mind? Andrew, we’ll start with you on this one.

Andrew:
Matt touched on it earlier, and that’s look beyond the first deal. You’re not looking to get rich or retire on one deal. Your first deal is the start of the business. Even if you’re just looking to, hey, do a few deals on your own, build your own portfolio, one deal is not going to be it. That first deal is just the start. So begin with that end in mind and look at the first deal and the second deal and the third deal as stepping stones or even building blocks in doing that.
Then we don’t have a lot of time to get into this, but if I was starting out net right now, a key thing is I would go educate myself big time on the debt markets, how they function. Commercial debt is very different than residential debt. I would go out and educate myself on how that works, what kind of loan options are available for the types of properties I’m looking at. How do you educate yourself? Podcasts, books, but talk to lenders, say, “Hey, I’m looking at this deal. Here’s my business plan for what debt options are there.” They will educate you. So I would do that and make sure that the debt that I choose fits my business plan for that property.

Matt:
Yeah. Just to go further on, and by the way, there’s newsletters you can subscribe to. You don’t have to become as smart as Andrew is. No. It’s not possible with regards to finance and debt and everything like that. There are newsletters you can read. So for neophytes like myself, I read newsletters so I can use words as smart as Andrew does that he knows automatically about these things. All joking aside, Andrew and I probably read a lot of the same publications on these things in that. So you don’t have to become an expert on it, you just have to be plugged into the streams of data that are out there on finance.
Ask any mortgage broker if they can give you access to some of the newsletters and the reports that they get because a lot of times they’re public and ask them. A good mortgage broker will spend some time educating you on how debt for multifamily works because it’s very different than debt for single family or small multi. Debt for multi gets a lot more complex and it’s worth taking the time to get educated on.
Next, the money in multifamily, yeah, you get a reasonable acquisition fee, and then I think that may be why some people are enamored with multifamily because if you design the deal properly, you get a little shot in the arm when you close, but let’s be clear. We’re not doing the deal for the acquisition fee. We’re doing the deal to create long-term wealth for our investors and for ourselves by joining them in the long game of this multifamily project, which is manifested through asset management, which is bringing about the business plan that you’ve designed when you bought the property.
Multifamily is not about the acquisition. It’s not. It is about the long road. If you play the multifamily game right, the check you’ll get when the property sells or when you do a disposition years down the road will be multiples larger for you. If you do right by your investors, that check will be multiples larger than any acquisition fee you could ever take in buying a deal.
So do the deal for the back end and for doing right by your investors and sticking your dismount, nailing that business plan exactly, which is achieved through the part of multifamily ownership nobody wants to talk about it. Everybody else talk about finding deals and funding deals, but really, the money is in asset management.

Andrew:
Yeah. Well said. Then that’s another big difference from single family is in multifamily, the money is absolutely in asset management. Going back to, Matt, what you said about the long term. I don’t know if you remember, but you and I, about five or six years ago, maybe even longer, we were sitting in the hallway at a GoBundance event in some mountain town in January. There were some challenging acquisitions and part of the conversation was like, “Man, when does this really pay off because this is a lot of hard work.” Where we land is, well, it really pays off five to seven years down the road when all the acquisition and the asset management pays off. So again, have that mindset going into it is-

Matt:
You were right about that deal. You were right. I remember I was like, “You know what Andrew said that it’ll pay off eventually with you rent buyer investors and do asset management properly and run a good business plan and it’ll pay off in the long run.” I had faith that you were right about that and you were. You do right by deals and run a good management strategy and it’s going to hit.

Andrew:
Right. So the acquisition fees and the management fees, you’re not going to get wealthy off of that. That pays your bills until you’ve built a successful personal portfolio or a successful multifamily business. Then five plus years down the road, that’s when it starts to really, really pay off.
Another thing I would say is, and I’ve fallen prey to this probably maybe, I don’t know, maybe, Matt, you have or not, but don’t compare yourselves to others, right? I mean, I have a perfect example. I have a friend in Texas who I had just bought a deal and he was in the loan business and he sat down and was like, “Hey, how are you doing this?” I explained the whole syndication process and all of that, right?
Then the next thing I know, he quits, and as of today, I think he’s literally done six times as many units as I have. It’s hard for me to not be like, “Man, why haven’t I done what he did? What the heck?” Don’t get me wrong. He’s a brilliant guy. I mean, that’s part of it. I mean, the guy, he just knew. He just needed a little nudge and, bam, he put the pieces together and knocked out of the water.
So it’s good to look at people like that who are ahead of you as inspiration and say, “Okay. Maybe I want to get there,” but whatever you do, don’t compare and say, “Oh, why can’t I do that?” because there’s always someone who’s bigger, better, smarter, faster, prettier, handsome, well, especially handsome if we’re talking about me, but to compare yourself and feel bad about, but rather, look and say, “Okay. I want to be there and I’ll get there someday as long as I stick with it.” Then of course, always listen to BiggerPockets, and don’t make snow angels in dog parks.

Matt:
I don’t know whose metaphors I love more, Davids or Andrews, honestly. I mean, maybe I can put it to a vote, but both your metaphors actually are cracking me up.

David:
Andrew’s got a book of jokes that I think that he reads before he comes on these podcasts because they’re always just one liner dad joke that just hits and he never uses the same one twice. It’s like 500 dad jokes for life or something, and before Andrew goes on any podcast or he goes on, he arms himself with five good ones. That’s how I feel like it works. My analogies are always-

Matt:
Yeah. I’ve heard a few of them before. I’ve heard the grass is greener over the septic tank before. So Andrew does recycle. He does recycle. So going back to comparing yourself to others, man, somebody gave me a good piece of wisdom, which is comparison is the thief of all joy, and it’s also the thief of a lot of education because if you look at that person that you were talking about, the mortgage broker that’s now done 8x more deals or whatever, maybe it’s brought the phone call.
Instead of throwing shade at him and being like, “Man, how’d you do that? They must be doing something wrong or whatever,” call him up, “Hey, tell me. Let’s collaborate,” or whatever, and I’m sure you did that because I know that’s something, that you would call them up and ask the question, but to the listener, if you see somebody growing like crazy that you know personally and throwing lots of stuff on Facebook or whatever about how all these acquisitions they’re doing, have the courage to give them a call and say, “Hey, help me/ show me how you’re doing that,” and most generous people in the world and most successful people are extremely generous are going to give you at least a couple of tips, and take those and glean them and then go and pass them. Go do more deals than they’re doing. All joking aside, just go and walk your own journey and don’t worry about what the guy next to you or gal next to you is walking.

David:
All right. Let’s sum up what you guys would be, keeping in mind if you were getting started over right now. Number one, begin with the end in mind, both with your business as a whole and on each deal. Number two, understand debt and how big of an impact it has on your success or failure. Like Andrew mentioned, remember that commercial debt and residential debt are not the same. Underpromise and overdeliver, always a good key to live life by. In multifamily especially, the money is truly made in operations, so don’t just focus on acquisitions at the expense of operational excellence.
The real payoff is five to 10 years down the road, so delay gratification. Don’t compare yourself with others, especially on social media. Like Matt said, comparison is the thief of joy. I will add on that. It can also be the source of joy if you are comparing yourself to people who are not doing as good as you to feel good about yourself. That is just as bad because if you start to depend on, “Oh, I’m doing better than that person,” then you’re going to feel like crap when someone comes along who’s doing better than you. So leave both of them alone and just stay in your lane.
Never do a deal just to get the acquisition fee. Do great deals and the fees and profits will follow. I will follow up with that and say be careful of who you’re doing your syndication with because there are other people out there that make their living off those acquisition fees and can be very tempted to stretch that deal past where the buttons on the pants are actually comfortable holding to get that money, especially if they’re on tight times.
Then finally, stay tuned to BiggerPockets, where we teach you all this stuff for freaking free. Can’t be any better. Guys, this has been an awesome interview. I’ll give each of you a chance to get a last comment in before I let you go. Matt, let’s start with you.

Matt:
So David, everything you just said, amazing. One thing that I wanted to get out there earlier that I didn’t get a chance to say is that people that are listening, maybe listening to this saying, “Well, right now’s not the right time and I’m going to wait for the right time to invest in real estate,” here’s the deal. I shot a video on my YouTube channel in 2016 about the potential multifamily real estate crash. We are always trying to predict a future in the world, but guess what? Everybody’s crystal ball is broken. Nobody knows what the future’s going to hold. Nobody knows there’s going to be a recession, if there’s going to be this, there’s going to be that. There’s always the right time. Find the right deal and find something that works in today’s economy and give yourself a little bit of conservatism and a couple of outs and understand that there’s going to be a way for you to make it work in today’s market.
Also, finally, understand that fear is going to be a real factor for no matter what in the market is. There’s never going to be this no problem market, that there’s nothing in your way, and it’s completely clear, and there’s no competition, and the deals are cheap, and the money’s free, and whatnot. That’s utopia real estate. Not going to happen. Don’t wait for utopia real estate to happen. Just find a way to make deals work today and be conservative enough that the deals will work out. If you hold long enough and you do the correct business plan, as Andrew said, it will eventually profit if you hold for the long term.

Andrew:
Well said. Yeah. What I would add to that is, and we talked about this, of taking the fear and turning it to your advantage, and then also, it will and should never completely go away. You never want to get to the point where you’re just like, “Oh, I’m going to buy these deals,” and you don’t give it any second thought, right? It’s good to once in a while second guess yourself and wake up at 3:00 in the morning and go, “I’m going to check those rent comps one more time,” because especially if you’re using other people’s money, and again, that fear doesn’t drive you, you’re using it to make yourself a better business person.
Then also, keep in mind, more so in my experience than any other type of real estate, getting started in multifamily is the hardest part. It gets easier the more you do it and the bigger you get, but the toughest part is the part that we just talked about, finding your market, getting over that fear, getting to know the market, making those phone calls, “What kind of property am I going to look at? How do I analyze them?” Actually, just doing all of that unknown stuff that once you get the first deal and then the second and then the third, you have those relationships, you have those skills, you have that team, you have the funds, it gets easier and easier and easier.
So if I was starting today, I would just approach it with the mindset of knowing, “Okay. This first part is just going to be grueling, but after that, it’s going to get easier and easier.”

David:
All right. Andrew, Matt, I really appreciate it. This was a fantastic show just like every single time that we guys have you on. It is a literal master class in multifamily investing. So thank you very much for sharing your knowledge. I also want to say, I would say my opinion multifamily investing probably is at the flavor of the month right now. I think short-term rentals are dominating in that space, but real estate is cyclical. It will have its day. Now is the time to be learning stuff. Arm yourself with knowledge because you’re going to be seeing, especially in my opinion in the next three to four years, I think a lot more opportunity in multifamily than what we’ve had in the last maybe 10 or so.
So bookmark this episode. Listen to it. Arm yourself with the information and be ready because opportunities will come. Thank you guys very much. This is David Greene for Matt “Captain America” Faircloth and Andrew “Hawkeye” Cushman signing off.

 

Help us reach new listeners on iTunes by leaving us a rating and review! It takes just 30 seconds and instructions can be found here. Thanks! We really appreciate it!

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Check out our sponsor page!

Note By BiggerPockets: These are opinions written by the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of BiggerPockets.



Source link


Fitch Group, the parent of bond-rating firm Fitch Ratings, is acquiring a majority ownership stake in capital-markets fintech company dv01 — which provides data and analytics services to the structured-finance market.

Terms of the deal were not disclosed. It is expected to close by the end of the third quarter, according to Fitch Group, which also is the parent of data, research and analytics provider Fitch Solutions.

Once the acquisition is completed, dv01, founded in 2014, will operate as a subsidiary of Fitch solutions. The loan-level data and analytics provided by dv01 assists clients across the investment-workflow spectrum, from market due diligence to securitizations to performance analysis. Its products include Loan Data Agent for Securitizations, Portfolio Surveillance, Market Surveillance and Credit Facility Management.

“Fitch’s resources will strengthen our position as a leading data-intelligence company in structured finance, allowing us to deepen our footprint in current asset classes, develop new products and ultimately expand into new markets,” said Perry Rahbar, CEO of dv01.

The dv01 deal is the latest in a series of acquisitions by Fitch Group. Previous acquisitions include Fulcrum Financial Data in 2018, CreditSights in 2021 and GeoQuant earlier this year.

Ted Niedermayer, president of Fitch Solutions, said the acquisition of dv01 “underscores Fitch Solutions’ commitment to empowering our clients with critical insights and intelligence to identify opportunities and manage risks.”

Fitch Group, which is owned by Hearst Corp., has dual headquarters in London and New York.

The post Fitch Group adding capital-markets fintech dv01 to its fold appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


Home-equity lending is on a roll this year, with the combined volume of home-equity lines of credit (HELOCs) and traditional closed-end home equity loans up 47% from January to May of 2022, compared with the same period last year.

Nearly $69 billion in HELOC credit limits and $27 billion in closed-end home-equity loans were originated over the first five months of 2021. That compares with $101 billion in HELOC volume and $38 billion in closed-end home-equity originations over the same period this year, according to a new report by the Urban Institute’s Housing Finance Policy Center.

Closed-end home-equity loans generally carry a fixed interest rate and involve a single lump-sum disbursement at the beginning of the loan, with repayment beginning immediately. HELOCs, by contrast, are revolving debt generally featuring a variable interest rate, like credit cards, and normally do not involve a single lump-sum disbursement. Instead, HELOCs offer two distinct periods during the term of the loan — a 10-year draw period and a 15-year repayment period, for example.

“With the economics of cash-out refinance worsening amidst higher rates, homeowners are showing increased willingness to use home equity lines of credit (HELOC) and home equity loans to tap equity,” the recent Housing Finance Policy Center report states.

The increasing popularity of home-equity loans also is expected to help revitalize interest in aggregating HELOCS for residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) offerings, which have been nearly nonexistent since the 2008 global financial crisis, according to a recent HELOC-focused report by bond-rating firm DBRSMorningstar.

“A few HELOC securitizations have been issued recently, after having been non-existent in the post-financial-crisis era…,” the DBRS Morningstar report states. “More potential issuers have looked to add HELOC securitization funding this year, especially given the dramatic rise in home values providing increased home-equity availability. 

“As HELOC originations grow from both bank and nonbank financial lenders, HELOC RMBS may see additional issuer opportunities, and structure formats will likely adapt to the unique features and risk aspects of the HELOC products of today.”

The DBRS Morningstar report also points out that nonbanks have started offering HELOCs that feature “slight variations on the traditional depository HELOC form,” such as shorter terms, fixed rates and an option for a lump-sum disbursement during the draw period. Among the nonbanks that either have or plan to introduce HELOC loan products are Rocket MortgageGuaranteed RateloanDepot and New Residential Investment Corp. (recently rebranded as Rithm Capital).

DBRS Morningstar’s report also notes that from 2019 to the present, a total of only nine residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) offerings have been completed involving HELOCs as collateral.

One of those deals made its way to the market this year. That deal, dubbed GRADE 2022-SEQ2, was a $198.6 million RMBS offering sponsored by Saluda Grade Opportunities Fund LLC. It was backed by 2,327 loans that included a mix of both closed-end second-lien mortgages and HELOCs, according to a presale report by Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA) . 

The loan originator for the RMBS offering was Spring EQ LLC, which focuses on originating second-lien mortgages, including closed-end home equity loans and HELOCs. The initial note purchaser for the RMBS offering, which closed in April of this year, was Raymond James & Associates, according to the KBRA report.

The spike in home-equity lending also was called out by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, which noted in its second-quarter 2022 Household Debt and Credit Report that limits on HELOCs jumped by $18 billion in the second quarter of this year. The jump represents “the first substantial increase in HELOC limits since 2011,” and is an indicator of an increase in new originations. HELOC balances stood at $319 billion for the second quarter, according to the Federal Reserve report.

“Balances on home-equity lines of credit (HELOCs) increased by $2 billion [in Q2], a modest increase but one that follows many years of declining balances,” the Fed report continued.

Another report by TransUnion shows the number of HELOC originations nationwide, based on the credit bureau’s analysis, jumped from 207,422 for second-quarter 2021 to 291,736 for the second quarter of this year — a 41% increase.

In addition, one of the largest lenders in the country, Bank of America, also reported a big jump in overall home-equity loan originations over the first six months of 2022 — from about $1.7 billion in 2021 to $4.6 billion this year based on the principal amount of the total line of credit, according to the bank’s second-quarter 2022 earnings report. HELOC’s were not broken out separately in that report.

“Cash-out refinance volumes are likely to remain muted for the foreseeable future as most borrowers will be reluctant to give up their ultra-low rates,” the Housing Finance Policy Center report states. “This suggests that demand for HELOCs and home-equity loans will remain strong, especially given the supply shortage and substantial equity build-up for existing homeowners. 

“We would also expect home-equity credit availability to improve as mortgage lenders look for ways to approve more borrowers to keep volumes flowing.”

The post HELOC volume up nearly 50% over first 5 months of 2022 appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


Lending standards tightened in August amid a worsening economic outlook and signs of cooling in home-price growth.

The mortgage credit availability index (MCAI) fell marginally by 0.5% to 108.3 in August from the previous month, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA). A decline in MCAI, benchmarked to 100 in March 2012, indicates that lending standards are tightening while an increase in the index suggests a loosening of credit.

“Mortgage credit availability declined slightly in August, as investors reduced their offerings of ARM and non-QM loan programs,” said Joel Kan, MBA’s associate vice president of economic and industry forecasting. Kan added that some lenders continue to streamline their operations by dropping certain loan programs to simplify their offerings, with origination volume expected to shrink about 48% to $2.3 billion in 2022 from last year’s $4.4 billion. 

“With a worsening economic outlook and signs of cooling in home-price growth, the appetite for riskier loan programs has been reduced,” Kan said.

Conventional MCAI, which does not include loans backed by the government, decreased 1%, and Government MCAI, which examines FHA, VA and USDA loan programs remained essentially unchanged. Of the component indices of the Conventional MCAI, the Jumbo MCAI fell by 0.7% and the Conforming MCAI decreased by 1.2%. 

The drop in mortgage credit availability follows volatile mortgage rates that closed out August at 5.8%, according to Black Knight’s Optimal Blue OBMMI pricing engine before retreating in July. With the fifth interest rate hike expected this month following the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting, the 30-year fixed rate jumped to 5.98% as of September 12. 

Offsetting the decline in mortgage credit availability decrease was a small increase in new Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC), a revolving line of credit that allows borrowers to draw money against the credit line up to a preset limit. While tappable equity, defined as the amount a homeowner can borrow against while keeping a 20% equity stake, is expected to decline this quarter, it hit a record of $11.5 trillion in the previous quarter. 

“With aggregate home equity still at elevated levels, HELOCs could benefit borrowers who might want to give up on their current, low mortgage rate but do want to utilize their home equity to support other spending plans,” Kan said.

Amid a rapid decrease in mortgage originations, nonbank lenders have been capitalizing on climbing home equity, a space that was dominated by depository banks. 

In August, Rocket Mortgage and its wholesale arm Rocket Pro TPO started offering home equity loans and Guaranteed Rate introduced a digital HELOC. Companies that plan to roll out HELOC products include loanDepot and New Residential Investment Corp. 

The post Lending standards tighten as appetite for riskier loans drops appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


Seattle and London-based construction technology company Modulous has raised $11.5 million in its Series A funding around, according to an announcement on Monday.

The firm said the funding will help further the growth of its physical and digital technologies. Main contributors to this round of funding included SFV, the venture arm of German real estate developer Patrizia; Regal London, a U.K-based real estate developer, CEMEX Ventures, the venture arm of construction giant CEMEX; Blackhorn Ventures (U.S.); GroundBreak Ventures (Canada); Goldacre (U.K.); and Leela Capital (U.K.).

Founded in London in 2018, Modulous uses a software platform to automate the design, cost planning and programming of modular multifamily construction projects using its pre-configured set of sub-assemblies, which it calls its “kit of parts.” Modulous’s software generates designs and massing for a given build site based on the firm’s physical “kit of parts,” including 3D visualizations and cost plans, which give developers real-time insight on return-on-investment calculations.

“The five co-founders, we all have backgrounds in construction and in 2017 we were all working together and we lost five big projects, about half a year’s worth of work, in one week and we knew we couldn’t carry on the way we were doing things,” Chris Bone, the firm’s CEO said. “So, we decided to digitize ourselves. We had no clue what we meant by that, but we knew that all the other industries were digitizing themselves, but for some reason, construction seemed to remain very backward in how things were done.”

Modulous works with supply chain partners, which includes US Gypsum and Hilti, to create its kits. The firm says its partners have focused their collaboration on reducing the number of components required to produce the Kit materials. This approach has made it possible to measure and calculate the accurate carbon content of a scheme, and to ensure the use of healthy, non-toxic materials.

Kits include things like floor panels, wall panels, ceiling panels and wet walls that can be assembled to form a module. Bone says it takes five people three hours to put together a module. The assembled modules are then brought to the construction site where the interior finished and exterior façade are added.

In addition, the firm says its platform and production methods enables 50% faster project delivery, 60% reduction in embodied carbon, and 70% reduction in construction waste.

“If you have ever put together a Meccano toy set you know how much harder and more time consuming it is to build one of those than a Lego set,” Bone said. “Meccano is like the traditional building method and Lego is the Modulous building method.”

The post Construction tech startup Modulous raises $11.5 million appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


Inflation is expected to continue “to decline across all horizons” over the next year while home prices, too, are projected to decline “sharply” to the lowest level since July 2020, according to the most recent Survey of Consumer Expectations (SCE) released by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

The median one-year inflation expectation, the August SCE report shows, fell to 5.7%, down from 6.2% in July. Median home-price growth expectations fell by 1.4 percentage points in August compared with July, to 2.1%, which is the lowest SCE reading since July 2020.

“The decline was broad-based across demographic groups and geographic regions,” the August SCE report states.  “Home-price expectations have now fallen by nearly two-thirds since the April 2022 reading of 6.0%.”

The SCE report is based on a nationally representative, internet-based survey of a rotating panel of some 1,300 heads of household. The report’s findings for August echo analysis of home-price data released in July by Black Knight Data & Analytics.

“Annual home-price growth shifted from deceleration to decline in July as the median home price fell 0.77% from June – the largest single-month decline since January 2011…,” Black Knight reported in its July Mortgage Monitor report. “Escalating declines in June and July have total tappable equity down 5% over the past two months, suggesting a sizeable reduction is likely in Q3, which would mark the first quarterly decline in three years.”

The Black Knight report notes that some of the most significant declines in tappable equity are occurring in equity-rich West Coast markets.

“From April through July, San Jose lost 20% of its tappable equity,” Black Knight Data & Analytics President Ben Graboske said. “Seattle followed, shedding 18% of tappable equity over that same three-month span. 

“Likewise, San Diego (-14%), San Francisco (-14%) and Los Angeles (-10%) have all seen double-digit declines since April.”

The amount of tappable home equity nationally hit $11.5 trillion in the second quarter of this year — after accounting for homeowners retaining at least 20% equity, according to Black Knight.

“With prices continuing to correct and our … HELOC data showing home-equity lending at its highest level in 12 years, we will keep a very close eye on equity positions in the coming months,” Black Knight’s July Mortgage Monitor report states.

Goldman Sachs, in a recent white paper titled “The Housing Downturn: Further to Fall,” projects that new and existing home sales are expected to drop by 22% and 17%, respectively, in 2022. 

Still, despite the dour projections for the housing market ahead as we enter the third quarter of 2022, home prices through the second quarter of year reached a high plateau. Average home prices were up significantly in the second quarter of this year, to $525,000, compared with $440,600 for the same period in 2021, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. The median sales prices in the second quarter of this year was $440,300, compared with $382,600 for the second quarter of last year, the report shows. 

“Higher home pricing and mortgage rates continue to curb homebuyer demand,” states Mortgage Capital Trading in its September 12 daily market report. “Mortgage rates climbed from 3.1% for a 30-year fixed in June 2020 to 5.8% on June 23, 2022, based on Freddie Mac’s rate-survey data. 

“With a 3% down payment, this has pushed the average mortgage payment from roughly $1,900 to over $3,400 a month, taking home price and rate increases into consideration.”

Even if the inflation rate is finally moderating, however, don’t expect a break from the aggressive upward rate push by the Federal Reserve’s Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) in its battle to stem rising inflation. Its next meeting is slated for September 20-21. 

A recent “Fed Chatterbox” report from investment bank Goldman Sach’s Economics Research unit states that “several participants suggested that the FOMC could hike [rates] by either 75 or 50 basis points in September.”

“Chair Powell noted that, following the two 75 basis-point hikes in June and July, ‘another unusually large increase could be appropriate’ at the September meeting,” the Goldman Sachs report continues. “Last week, the Wall Street Journal reported that the FOMC ‘appears to be on a path to raise interest rates by another 0.75 percentage point this month,’ a likely hint from the Fed leadership that a 75 basis-point hike is coming at the September meeting. 

“No FOMC participant has argued against delivering a 75 basis-point hike, and a few participants indicated that they preferred to frontload rate increases.”

The post Inflation, home prices headed downward: Fed report appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


Fraud risk for mortgages declined 7.5% in the second quarter for this year compared to 12 months ago, but income and property fraud incidents are likely to rise, CoreLogic forecasts.

In the second quarter of 2022, about 1 in 131 mortgage applications contained fraud while 1 in 120 applications were fraudulent in the same period last year. The decline is partially due to a different scoring model in the first quarter of 2022 but higher risks were recorded for income and property frauds, according to a mortgage fraud report published by CoreLogic.

Risks of income fraud rose 27.3% and property fraud climbed 22.6%, posting the largest year over year increase in the second quarter of 2022.

The trend is not surprising, considering that purchase loans, which account for more mortgage transactions than refinances these days, are more susceptible to fraudulent activity, the report said.

“Income fraud risk remains a top concern for lenders, but there is a rising focus on property value risk as home prices slow their growth and homes are taking longer to sell,” said Bridget Berg, principal at industry & fraud solutions at CoreLogic. “Our most predictive flags for both income and property frauds increased more than 20% in the last year more than 20%.” 

According to the report, income fraud can come from a variety of areas such as doctored paystubs or W-2s to longer term falsification schemes involving using false information with “seasoned” bank account information. Nationally, five of the six mortgage fraud types, except undisclosed real estate debt, showed increased risks since the second quarter of 2021. 

The Department of Justice’s press releases show the extent of mortgage fraud problems and its national reach. 

Former executives of mortgage lender Vanguard Funding were each sentenced to prison to more than 18 months for pocketing millions more than $8.9 million of warehouse loans from lenders by claiming that the loan proceeds would fund home mortgages and refis. According to federal authorities, the three executives used the funds to pay personal expenses and compensation to pay off loans they obtained through false loan applications.

In a separate incident, a real estate investor was convicted for inflating a debt amount of $915,000 in a $1.3 million refinance mortgage loan secured by a former city official in San Francisco. A federal jury convicted the investor of making false statements and bank fraud, which could put the investor in 30 years of maximum imprisonment and a $2 million fine for the two counts the jury convicted. 

Another indicator of mortgage fraud are Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) that financial institutions must file with federal regulators to comply with the Bank Secrecy Act when they suspect criminal activity might be occurring. The U.S. Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) tracks those filings and publishes the aggregate findings on its website.

A tally of FinCEN’s SARs data collected between 2014 and 2021 shows that total filings have generally trended upward since 2014 across depository institutions (banks); finance companies, which includes nonbank mortgage lenders; and the government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

In the specific area of mortgage fraud, however, SARs filings have trended downward at depository institutions, from a high of 35,528 filings in 2014 to 8,805 filings in 2021. The decrease in filings coincides with the rise of nonbanks as a major source of originations in the country.

The post Mortgage fraud risk is increasing amid slow real estate market appeared first on HousingWire.



Source link


Real estate investors are a hard-working bunch. They put in long hours every day to create passive income and find financial freedom. Many investors resort to doing what they hate, day in and day out, simply to escape the clutches of a nine-to-five job. If you’re a rookie real estate investor, you’re probably the property manager, head of acquisitions, tenant contact, and accountant all rolled into one. But this “all or nothing” way of working could slow you down faster than you know.

If you want to take your wealth to the next level, try quitting—it’s what Pat Hiban and Tim Rhode have been doing for decades. As two successful real estate agents, they enjoyed the negotiation games that eventually led to large commission checks. But as the years went by, this non-stop grind took its toll—so much that they both gave up very profitable professions to do what they love. Surprisingly, the “do what you love” lifestyle made them even more money than before!

This is all well and good for a couple of veteran investors, but what about our real estate rookies? What about you, listening to this with one, two, or ten deals? How do you take a step back and become a quitter like Pat and Tim? Can you really make more money by doing less, and even if you could, how do you take the first step? In their new book, The Quitter’s Manifesto, Pat and Tim lay out the exact team and strategy you need to go from burnout to big checks with far less effort.

Ashley:
This is Real Estate Rookie episode 216.

Pat:
And I think the number one rule to being a good mentee is actually taking the advice of the mentor. A lot of people come to me and I say, “Read this book and do this, and do that,” and I never hear from them again. But when I hear back from somebody that’s like, “Pat, I read all three of the books. Here’s a picture of all the notes I took. I did exactly what you said. I went out there and did this and did that,” I’ll be like, “Great. Stay in touch.”

Ashley:
My name is Ashley Kehr, and I’m here with my co-host, Tony Robinson.

Tony:
And welcome to the Real Estate Rookie Podcast where every week, twice a week, we’ll bring you the inspiration, information, education, and motivation you need to kickstart your investing journey. And I’d usually like to start the shows by giving a quick shout out to the folks that have left us a review. This week’s review comes from Yuri to Wealth, and she says, “Best podcast for people getting started.” Yuri says, “This podcast has helped me stay motivated and want to level up and become financially free. It amazes me hearing other people’s stories, and I always learned a thing or two from every episode. I am so glad this podcast exists.” So, Yuri, we appreciate that. And if you haven’t yet, please leave an honest rating and review on whatever platform you’re listening to. The more reviews we get, the more folks we can reach. More folks to reach, more folks we help. So Ashley, we’ve got a really, really good episode lineup for today, right? Two just absolute juggernaut to the game. One of them is a self described OG, legit real estate investor. So, I’m excited for people to listen today.

Ashley:
Yeah, we have Pat and Tim on today who just wrote the book for BiggerPockets, The Quitter’s Manifesto, and they are going to break down why this is important for a rookie investor to actually take a read. They go through as to how they quit their careers to go into new careers or new passions. And a big thing they brought up several times is that the goal was to not do any obligations but to do your passions, to do what you wanted to do. And I think that’s really awesome and sometimes all of us need that reminder in life.

Tony:
Yeah. That part really struck a chord with me. They talked about moving from 100% obligation to 100% interest, and I feel, right now, I’m 90% obligation, even 95% obligation, 5% interest. So, that part really resonated with me, and more so, they give you some instruction on how to do that. So first, these guys, they run the company called GoBundance. So basically, their entire working life, all they do is talk, and teach, and network with super successful entrepreneurs in all forms of business.

Ashley:
Let’s just name drop and say Brandon Turner, David Greene, [inaudible 00:02:55] and look at them. That’s amazing.

Tony:
Exactly. And there’s a lot of other really successful folks in that group. And both Pat and Tim have a knowledge of things to just open up your mind as an entrepreneur. They talked about journaling and how to make that the most useful. We spent a good chunk of this episode talking about mentorship, and not just the benefits of it, but practical, tactical ways you can go out and find a mentor that I think will really resonate with a lot of the folks that are earlier on in their journey.

Ashley:
And how to be a good mentee too, I think it’s really important that they talk about.

Tony:
So many good things. And they also talk about the progression you go through in your business, when it comes to you’re starting out at the ground level and what it looks like once you’ve built a successful business and how to get there. So, this conversation usually could have gone on for two hours. These guys are phenomenal, a wealth of knowledge, and I’m excited for you guys to hear it.

Ashley:
Tim and Pat, welcome to the show. Thank you guys so much for joining us. Can we get started with Tim, maybe you going first, and just telling us a little bit about yourself and who you are?

Tim:
Sure. Well, I was the least likely to succeed in your class, going back to high school. Barely graduated high school, never went to college, and at 25, I was a part-time grocery clerk, not getting enough hours and trying to do side hustles to make money for my two small kids. Then I found my niche selling real estate. I sold a lot of real estate, I was damn good at it, really concentrated on coming through for whoever I went to work for. And then I also invested a lot in real estate while I was in the trenches. And I sold 17 properties with 52 tenants in 2008 right into the Cali craze, and tapped out and retired. And candidly, I’ve never worked since. So, that’s-

Ashley:
That’s quite the story.

Tim:
Yeah. It was fun. Yeah. So, we wrote this book, Quitter’s Manifesto, about how to quit whatever you’re doing. And Pat and I are the original quitters and we become very, very good at quitting what’s behind us to tap dance to the next incarnation. So, that’s what this book’s all about and we’re excited to share it with your listeners.

Ashley:
Pat, what about you? Who are you? What’s your story?

Pat:
Who is Pat Hiban? I don’t know. I’m in a lot of therapy to try to figure that one out.

Ashley:
Yeah. Let’s dig deep here.

Pat:
So, a little bit different story than Tim. I went to college but I got a 2.3 GPA in sociology. And I found I couldn’t get hired really, the jobs weren’t big for sociologists. So, I got into a job with the least barrier to entry, and that was real estate sales. And started at 21, worked all the way until 46, 47 years old, selling real estate. Sold a lot of houses, made a lot of commissions one house at a time, and just worked my way through the ranks of about five different major companies. Had my own company, had a mortgage company, had a title company, did everything in that realm. And then I just got out, I just exploded, I don’t want to do it anymore. And that was that. Then at that point, I did a four or five ventures that just failed, that I just seemed like a good idea at the time scratching some itch, but didn’t pay and didn’t work.
So then, eventually, Tim and I, along with a couple other guys, started a men’s mastermind called GoBundance. And now, between our women’s group, our men’s group, and our rookie group, we have over a thousand members, 1,020 members, paying members. Just a miracle really. And then I also started investing. I started buying, first, single family homes, then multi-family homes. I think with my company, DAPT Acquisitions, we have about 2000 doors. But some other various commercial real estate, sold a bunch, and wrote a couple of books, and that’s where I am today.

Ashley:
Awesome you guys. So, part of the big reason that you guys are here is to talk about your book. So, let’s start with that, let’s go over that. It seems like you guys have accomplished a lot, you have a great stories, but let’s focus on the book and why did you even decide to write this book?

Tim:
I think the reason we wrote it is we’ve both done what most want to do but don’t know how to, and that is to go from obligation, 100% obligation, to as much as possible, 100% interest, doing things you love to do. And in the book, we have the interest over obligation quotient and we help people get to, let’s say, 80% doing what they love to do, interest, versus what most have to do, obligation. And that’s one of the premises of the book, that’s one thing Pat and I were able to do, is start in total obligation, that was selling real estate and doing the things we had to do daily, to juggling the other real estate to get us to a place where we could do what we want to do pretty much all the time.
And I found when I tapped out at 40 years old, I started doing a lot of time just getting the goods in the mountains, skiing a hundred days a year, doing things I really wanted to do, and that helped me, as well as Pat, start GoBundance, start DAPT, start figuring out what’s on the other side. And because so many are just focused, they’re on the hamster wheel and can’t get out, and that’s what this book does, is gives you the tools to go to what’s next for you.

Tony:
Yeah. So Tim, one follow up to that, I think for a lot of the rookies that are listening, obviously, I think a lot of their goals are to, at some point, focus on the things that interest them and not missed out their obligations. For example, we just interviewed another rookie investor and she said one of the obstacles to her getting started was that the idea of getting to that point seemed so far away that it seemed almost unreachable. So, what is your advice to people that are at the beginning of their journey that hear you guys talking about this wonderful life you’ve built for yourselves, but they don’t quite think that it’s possible to get there?

Tim:
Yeah, we would both say that. When we started, we didn’t think of it as possible. I don’t think either of us had this, begin with the end in mind, we’re going to be rich, we’re going to be spending a lot of time just doing the things we want to do, what we did, and Pat could probably back me up on this, it’s a matter of juggling balls. And we all have the career, the family, all the obligations we have, and the challenge is, how do you throw that new ball in, keep those other balls going and not lose one and not drop the whole thing? So, I think that’s the thing, is just taking… It’s like everybody wants to take the elevator to the top, you got to walk the stairs. And it’s just taking that next stair, whatever that is for you, and you know what it is for you. I shouldn’t say, you know what it is for you, it’s the answer, is getting quiet and seeking advice and getting out in nature to just get quiet enough to get those answers. And that’s the tough part.

Tony:
Yeah, I want to follow up to that. You talk about getting quiet, and that’s something I struggle with tremendously. Because we have so many moving pieces in our business, we’re just like, there’s always things to do, and my mind’s always racing. So, that’s just the way that I live my life unfortunately. So, what are some tactical steps that someone like me can take to find some of that quietness, and how do I get the best out of that quiet time, if that makes sense?

Pat:
Sure. One thing that Tim and I both do is journal. I probably have a hundred journals. I’ve journaled ever since I got out of college basically. No one I knew journaled growing up until I started meeting other successful people, like Tim and David, and find out that they journaled too. And I think it’s a sign of successful people. What happens when I journal is I manifest things. Every idea that I’ve ever had, every company I’ve ever had, every problem that I’ve ever had, I’ve journaled it out and tried to solve the problem in the journal. And sometimes, it doesn’t get solved in there, or it gets solved by a way I didn’t think of or by accumulative of seven or 10 days of journaling about the same thing. But it all passes through there and I think it’s very effective. It’s therapeutic but it’s also very effective in solving problems and in getting off the dime.
And also, I’m like you, Tony. I’m manic at times and I just come up with ideas, and a lot of them they don’t work, but it’s okay, because once I push them on the page, I might come back to it later and be like, “Yeah, that’s a dumb idea.” Or I talk to my wife about it and she’ll be like, “I don’t know. That’s not you.”

Ashley:
Tony, one thing that Brandon Turner has told me that he does is, he’ll get a massage every week and that’s his thinking time. Because you can’t do anything else but lay there and that’s when he has his quiet time to think. So, I would love to do that. So, Tony?

Tony:
That’s not a bad idea. That’s not a bad idea.

Ashley:
Does that mean since it’s for your business, it’s a write off too?

Tony:
It’s a write off. It’s got to be.

Pat:
Absolutely.

Tim:
And I remember when I was in the trenches, just walking outside and taking a walk around the block, if I couldn’t get out, and just getting my heart rate elevated and getting these ideas going through in my head and having a meeting with my board of directors in my head. And then when I had the time, I love the term, getting the goods in the woods, because that’s where all my best ideas ever came from. And whenever I could get out in nature with my heart rate elevated, it was magical and it was like tapping into the universe, if you will, and I come back with just these amazing ideas. I couldn’t wait to have my wife shoot them down, like camps.

Ashley:
Well, you briefly mentioned about the board of directors, can you expand on that a little bit more?

Tim:
Well, there is a piece in this book about having a quit team to help you actually quit, and I think, Pat, you should touch on that. But Napoleon Hill, in this great book, Think and Grow Rich, talked about a board of directors in your head. And if you look at all these different areas of our lives, maybe it’s business, maybe it’s exercise, maybe it’s relationships, having people that are mentors and coaches that help you get clarity of the things that are most important to you. And Pat and I have talked numerous times about this, first of all, both of us have two coaches right now in our lives. We’ve had a series of coaches throughout our lives.
I told you I never went to college, but I wish I would’ve kept score because I know I’ve spent somewhere between 500,000 and a million dollars on education. If you name any of the greats I saw back in the day, Jim Rohn, and Wayne Dyer, and Zig Ziglar, and so many, I could just go on and on with all the different programs I went through, and these people are like my coaches in my head, who I’ll hear their voices. And I think all that helps lead you to beyond what you think is possible.

Pat:
Yeah. And I’ll talk on the quitting. For anybody that wants to quit, we recommend creating a quitting team. And on the team, there’s four categories of people. You’ve got stakeholders, number one. Now a stakeholder would be like your spouse, loved ones, basically, someone who’s going to support you, someone who’s going to say I believe in you, someone who is going to listen to you when you tell them how hard it is, and the troubles that you’re having, and not discourage you. Those are your stakeholders, the people that are in this with you, from a side point of view, meaning, family. And the second one is partners. Now, these are actual people. They could be businesses that you use, suppliers, investors in your company, people like that that are not necessarily owners of the company, but they’re attached somehow. If you do well, they do well.
And they might be able to link you with other people or other businesses to do you a solid so that you do well, and thereby, they would do well, if that makes sense. The third box, and we have boxes in the book for you to fill out names and put at least a couple of names in each box as mentors. Now, mentors are not like this old dude with a beard and long white hair sitting underneath a tree somewhere-

Ashley:
In a blue shirt, headphones on right now.

Pat:
Exactly. This is somebody who actually is in your exact business, we’re a similar business. So, in real estate, this would be like someone who’s been in the… It’s funny, this is relative, I had dinner last night with a guy who owns a big real estate broker and he texted one of his agents and he said, “I’m having dinner with Pat Hiban.” And the guy goes, “Oh, I know of Pat Hiban. He’s the real estate OG, legit.”

Ashley:
That’s quite a compliment right there, right?

Tim:
Now he needs a beard.

Pat:
I was like, “Wow, I’ve been calling a lot of things but never real estate OG, legit.” I was like, “Okay.” So, that’s my rap name, real estate OG, legit. Anyways, so I would be a mentor to that kid. So, somebody who actually has done it and can save you time because they’ve already done it, they’ve already learned the lessons, they’ve already gotten their teeth kicked in so they can keep you from getting your teeth kicked in and save you time so you don’t have to make the mistakes that they made, that would be mentors. And then the last one is coaches. And coaches are different than mentors because the thing that coaches do is they offer the accountability piece. You’re paying them to be a drill sergeant or a personal trainer. You’re paying them to yell at you if you’re not doing things that are going to make you more money.
If you want to get into real estate investing, it would be doing drive-bys of vacant houses where you see high grass, and leaving them notes, or whatever the process is that’s going to make you money. There’s an accountability piece to a coach that a mentor’s not going to… there’s nothing in it for them, they’re not going to alienate you by being a jerk on purpose. But a coach will. A coach, you’re paying money to be a jerk to you on purpose. So, those are the four boxes and we encourage everybody, before they quit or go out in an endeavor of self-employment entrepreneurship, before they do that, fill out two names in each of those boxes.

Tony:
Pat, what a wonderful description of who you need to consult with in your life. And the one I want to drill down on, I think, is the mentors piece. Because for a lot of rookies that are listening, their dream is to find that mentor that’s going to hold their hand and share a lot of the wisdom and lessons learned that that mentor has and pass it along to this new real estate investor. So, if I’m someone that’s new, maybe I don’t necessarily have a big network myself of people that invest in real estate, which is true for a lot of new people, and Pat, I’ll ask it to you first, and Tim if you can follow up, but how can I, as a new investor, find that mentor that’s willing to give me the time and energy of sharing all those lessons?

Pat:
Go to BiggerPockets Convention. Really, that’s how. Here’s an interesting fact, I met Tim at a money convention in Chicago. I’m from Maryland, he’s from California. I was tying my shoes to go for a run in the lobby and he came out in running clothes and was going for a run. And we ended up running together and meeting. We were both interested in money. He had more money than me, he had a lot of real estate, which I didn’t have at the time, so he essentially became my mentor in that. He was also, and is, my mentoring quitting. When I met him, he was 41 or something, and he had just quit. So, I was like, “Wow, this dude quit at 40 years old. I need to run with him.”
But the point is, that’s the answer to your question, you got to put yourself out there with other people that would be your mentor and just grab him in the hall and just start talking to him. And everybody, guys like me, real estate OG, legit people, we’re egomaniacs, we love talking. We get high from talking to people. So, if a young person comes up and asks us questions, we’re not going to be a jerk to them. That’s reality.

Ashley:
Tim, before you go real quick, I want to follow up with Pat real quick on that. So, when you guys went for that run, I want to understand how you treated Tim or how the conversation went. Were you just all of a sudden like, “Here’s my chance, I’m going to drill him with questions,” or was it like, “Let me build a connection, a relationship, with this person and then we go into a mentorship”?

Pat:
So, this might not be the answer you think or recommend. So, first of all, I had happened to be talking to another guy that was Tim’s friend at a social cocktail party, or something, the night before and he’s like, “You got to meet my buddy Tim Rhode.” And so, I knew of him from literally the night before, and I guess, somehow, I might have known that that was him, or something, I’m not sure. But my personality is, and this is not good, I actually have a communication coach that I’m working with that try to change a little bit of this, but my personality is, sometimes, I go too fast into asking questions and it alienates people. They think I’m a private investigator working for their ex-husband or ex-wife or something. No, seriously, I had a woman asked me if I was an FBI agent pretty recently. There’s a story behind it, but I was curious about something and I was asking her too many questions.
So anyway, to answer your question, Tim and I connected over passive income, we connected over real estate, we connected over wealth. The seminar we happen to be at is called Money Matters. So, pretty much everybody there was there to talk about money. So, that’s what I did. We connected after. We grew as friends later, but during that run, it was like, “How many rental properties do you have? How much money…” You know what I mean?

Ashley:
That’s so interesting, and I like to hear both sides of it as to how people build a relationship. And Tim, did you have other people trying to talk to you because of your status at this point during that conference? And why did it end up being Pat that you built this relationship? Or do you have 5,000 Pats around you all the time that you’re friends to all of them?

Tim:
Actually, because of that Money Matters seminar, the next day I went running with David Osborne and Pat, and we became the three amigos. When we started our own mastermind, and that’s turned into GoBundance. And just to take that to the next level, you guys all know Andrew Cushman, he’s a regular on BiggerPockets show. When Pat talks about DAPT, it’s David, Andrew, Pat, and Tim. And Andrew is our horse, and he goes out and finds all the apartments. So, this is really a key piece for all the people that are listening to this is, it’s like we built a team together. We started really small and it was the three of us, and then GoBundance became, from those three, as Pat said, is now a thousand people. DAPT started off as one apartment complex because I knew Andrew from when I used to coach real estate investors and we plugged him in as the one finding all the deals.
So, the point to the listeners is, it’s who, not how. And it’s finding that piece that completes you. And Pat, David and I, together, just took us to another level in our lives of not just finances, but health and fitness, and relationships, and stuff, and we all fed off each other. I would like to touch on the, who did I find for mentors early on, and one was a guy in my hometown, his name was Johnny Viera. And when I changed my identity from Tim List and Sells Real Estate and buys a few rentals, about 2000, I decided I want to go full on into investing and quit listing and selling real estate. So, I made two moves. One, I wrote a plan called Tim is Now an Investor Plan. And two, I reached out to the biggest investor in my area, Johnny Viera, who owned 250 rentals at the time.
And I bought the dude breakfast. And that’s a key point in this, don’t just suck his head, ask what you can do for them. So, I wanted something from him, so I wanted to make darn sure I at least bought him breakfast. And he was so generous. Just like Pat said, he is way beyond. He just threw his cards on the table, or everything he was doing, I’m taking copious notes. And it really helped my investor game. So, I think that’s something that can really help, those around you, and obviously, being into investor meetings and stuff like that. It’s doing the homework, that’s part of those stairs, I was talking about, is doing the things, going to that seminar we went to. What a game changer. That $3,000 has been a $5 million hit.

Tony:
It’s good returns.

Tim:
Yeah.

Tony:
Now, I was just going to say, Tim, on the mentor piece, I want to talk a little bit about the team building too before we move on to that, just back to the mentorship really quickly, I know something that I struggle with is, and I have access to pretty successful entrepreneurs and real estate investors in my network, but I hate the idea of just going to them and asking for things and not being able to provide value in return. And it’s like what value can I give to someone that already has 3000 units? They have their team, they have this, they have that. So, if I’m a rookie, how do I identify ways to add value to these potential mentors? That way, they, I don’t know, maybe give me the time of day.

Tim:
I would find somebody who knows them and knows what they like and finds something you can do to add value to them. Honestly, just buying a breakfast wasn’t enough. It was very nice that he did that, but I would’ve maybe found somebody on his team and find something they’re really into and get him a gift or something like that. But it’s worth it. And it’s okay also just to reach out and say, “Hey, I know you don’t know me, but boy, would you mind spending 15 minutes, 30 minutes on a phone?” Something like that.

Pat:
A great question is, what can I do to earn the opportunity to have lunch with you?

Ashley:
Do you know what the answer would be if someone asked you that though? Because I don’t know what I would say to that, I guess.

Tony:
Same. Same.

Ashley:
Yeah, if someone said that to me. And I think that’s what I struggle with, is I have a lot of people that reach out to me on Instagram and say, “I’d love to work with you. What can I do for you at free time? I can do this.” But I don’t know what to even task them, or assign to them, or what they could send to me, or whatever.

Pat:
The answer to your question is that you don’t have to necessarily really give them something. It’s rhetorical. You’re hoping that they say, “Don’t worry about it, I’m happy to meet with you.” Logically thinking, they could say, “Well give a donation to my charity,” which a lot of rich people have charities that they are fond of or have their favorite charity, if not their own charity. And that works if they ask for that or if you want to do it. The other big thing that I actually talk about in my first book, 6 Steps to 7 Figures, is how to be a mentee, how to be a good mentee. And I think the number one rule to being a good mentee is actually taking the advice of the mentor. A lot of people come to me and I say, “Read this book and do this and do that.” And I never hear from them again.
But when I hear back from somebody that’s like, “Pat, I read all three of the books. Here’s a picture of all the notes I took. I did exactly what you said. I went out there and did this and did that.” I’ll be like, “Great. Stay in touch.” Because it makes me feel good that someone’s actually respecting the advice that I’m giving, because 99% of the people don’t do what you tell them they should do.

Tim:
That’s darn good, Pat. Spot on.

Tony:
I want to talk a little bit about the team building piece. Tim, you had mentioned about DAPT and how it came together, that Andrew was the workhorse that put that all together. So, as I’m looking to set myself up to quit, we talked about the stakeholder, the partners, the mentors, the coaches, but what about the team I actually need once I do quit? What does that part look like?

Tim:
Well, and Pat can relate the to this too, let’s look at three different levels. A, you’re a player in the game. B, you’re a general manager. And three, you’re an owner. And now Pat and I are like owners, but boom, when we were players deepening our bench, one thing that I said all along is, I suck. And my theory is, so many people, they want to do everything, “No one can do it like me.” I never had that problem. All I wanted to do was prospect and list homes back in the day. And one person at a time, I’d get somebody to do everything I don’t want to do. At one point I had five people doing all the things I want to do… or, excuse me, didn’t want to do, to lead me to success. So, I think when as a player, it’s getting the training wheels for yourself, learning what’s your MO, and boy, that’s something.
If you suffer from having to do everything yourself and think nobody can do it better, I challenge you to get out of your way because you’re really limiting yourself. And I’ve always, always, to this day, every single team we have, it’s full of top-notch players, and we don’t do anything, and I rarely did all along, as a player, as the GM, as the owner. I got much off my plate as early as I possibly could to just concentrate on my unique 10%.

Tony:
Tim, I love that. I want to hear from both of you. So Pat, maybe if you can answer first, and Tim, we’ll go back to you. But I think that’s every new investor’s dream, is to be able to build this business where they outsource all the stuff they hate doing, they’re really working in their area of expertise, just the thing that they’re uniquely skilled at doing. But building a team also requires money. And for the person that’s only got one unit, the idea of outsourcing everything doesn’t seem feasible because there’s just not enough revenue coming in. So, as you’re building your business, Pat, how do you know when to start bringing people in? And does it make sense to maybe give yourself a pay cut to start paying someone else to do some of the work that you were doing before?

Pat:
So, the answer is it always does at some point. You should do it yourself for 50 hours, maybe 60 hours a week. If you’re going to make this a full time thing as investing, you should actually work 50, 60 hours a week in building it in the beginning. And just imagine what you could make happen if you actually were dollar productive, meaning, you were actually calling people, or texting people, or leaving them notes, or knocking on the door, or whatever, how many leads you could get as far as houses to buy or whatever it is you’re trying to buy, whatever piece of real estate asset you’re trying to buy, if you did that. And then, because you worked 50, 60 hours a week doing dollar productive activities, meaning, things that make you money, you’re going to have more than one unit, you’re going to have lots going on and you’ll be able to afford to go to Upwork and find someone on Upwork to do what you want to do five hours a week at first, and then 10 hours a week, and then 20 hours a week, and then hire somebody full-time eventually.

Tony:
Yeah, that’s a great example. Tim, do you have anything to add to that?

Tim:
Yeah. When I was selling real estate my first full year in the business, I did what Pat said, I did everything myself, absolute just in the trenches, working my butt off, doing whatever it took to get the job done. I made 70,000 my first year, and I hired Diane McClanahan at 48,000 per year with four weeks paid vacation. She’s the best escrow officer in the area and I grabbed her. And just had this anchor who, as soon as I got it into escrow, I knew it was done and I went into just prospecting and listing. And then my second hire was somebody… as soon as I got the listing, they’d take it from there until it went to escrow. So yeah, doing all the things that I wasn’t good at. And pretty soon it was like, I’d say, “This is my team, here’s my phone number, but you’ll never call me.” They’re amazing, they do everything. And they did.

Tony:
Yeah, I do think that’s a common misconception, not just entrepreneurs or not just real estate investors, but entrepreneurs in general have is that they hear this, the “who, not how” and build the team and do this and do that, but they miss the fact that that’s a gradual process, and that it’s not supposed to be on day one, or day 30, or day 90, or day 180, or day 365, it’s years down that grind when you’ve really built that financial nest egg to be able to afford that team member, where you can start outsourcing things.

Tim:
You got to mop the floors.

Tony:
There You go.

Ashley:
Tim and Pat, my next question is along the same lines, as having the money to pay your team, but before even that, what kind of reserves or what should your financial position look like before you actually quit?

Tim:
Mine was not by the book, let’s just say. I think most people would want a little more in reserves than what I did. When I tapped out at 40, it wasn’t like I had a big massive reserve or big money was coming in, it was barely there. And I believed in myself, and just knew all the things that got me to this place was no longer working with me with my old incarnation, which was selling real estate. And then I want to, just for investing, I knew if I just worked at it and did the same thing I used to do just for I’m going to be the customer instead of the client, that I knew I could make it happen. So, my answer is yes, it’s wise to get money behind you and to have a nice cushy place to jump off. But sometimes, it’s time to just make the move and it’s best for you not to.

Ashley:
Well, thank you guys so much for joining us on the podcast. Can you let us know where everyone can find your book and where they can reach out to you guys?

Pat:
Yeah, that’s easy, biggerpockets.com/quittersmanifesto. Name of the book again is, The Quitter’s Manifesto, Quit a Job You Hate For the Work You Love. Quitter’s Manifesto. So yeah, we’re excited. BiggerPockets has been a great publisher for us and we think we have a really good book that’s going to help millions of people. Everyone that’s read it so far has given us rave reviews on it. So, I hope that anybody listening, go ahead and pick it up. It’s an easy read. It’s what we call an airplane read, which means you could buy it in an airport, read it on your flight, and be done when you land.

Tim:
Thanks for the opportunity, Ashley and Tony, and we’ll see you all at BiggerPockets Conference this fall in San Diego.

Ashley:
Yeah, that’s going to be October 2nd to the fourth, so we hope to see everyone there. If you haven’t checked it out yet, go to biggerpockets.com/events. And if you want to check out their new book, you can find it in the BiggerPockets Bookstore. So, Pat and Tim, thank you guys so much for coming on and we also look forward to meeting you guys there at the conference in sunny San Diego.

Tim:
Look forward to it.

Pat:
Look forward to meeting you guys.

Ashley:
I’m Ashley @wealthfromrentals, and he’s Tony @tonyjrobinson, and this has been another Rookie Reply.

 

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Check out our sponsor page!

Note By BiggerPockets: These are opinions written by the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of BiggerPockets.



Source link