The Federal Reserve played the good grinch for Christmas this year and delivered the best gift for homebuyers nationwide, leading to lower mortgage rates. The 10-year yield and mortgage rates fell together after the Fed meetings, which gave us mortgage rates under 7% last week.

Mortgage rates and the 10-year yield

What a crazy week! Not too long ago, on jobs Friday, I was on the HousingWire Daily podcast saying it’s time to declare war on the Federal Reserve for being too restrictive; you can listen to the podcast here. A few days later, the Fed corrected its mistake — they didn’t go hawkish but instead made doves cry and bond yields acted correctly, sending the 10-year yield below 4% and mortgage rates under 7%.

Right after the Fed presser I did another podcast where I outlined why this was so positive for the U.S. economy. You can see it in the stats from last week, where the 10-year yield fell from 4.25% to end the week at 3.91%. Mortgage rates went from 7.10% to 6.62% and ended the week at 6.64%.

As I have said before, given the history of economic cycles, when the market believes the Fed rate-hike cycle is over, bond yields will rally and mortgage rates will fall. We have had an almost 1.5% move lower in mortgage rates without one rate cut happening, and that looks normal to me. We shall see if we can hold those gains next week.

Purchase application data

Even before mortgage rates dropped below 7.25%, we saw a positive move in purchase application data, which continued last week with another week of gains. That means we’ve had a positive trend for the last five weeks. Purchase apps were up 4% week to week, and as crazy as it might sound, we could end the year with more positive weekly prints than negative as the year-to-date count is 23 positive and 23 negative, with two flats prints.

During the last two weeks of the year, nothing much usually happens with purchase apps as we prepare for Christmas and the New Year, but I will always track the data! But the fact that we can even talk about a positive year when mortgage rates got to 8% demonstrates something that I have been talking about since Nov. 9, 2022, and for many years: It’s rare the U.S. to have existing home sales trends below 4 million with any duration post-1996. We have a cores set of 4 million homebuyers every year for more than 25 years, and that hasn’t broken yet.

Weekly housing inventory data

Weekly active listing data is declining now like it always does every year at this time due to seasonality. Higher mortgage rates resulted in higher inventory during part of the fall and forced the seasonal decline in inventory to start later this year. However, the laws of seasonality always win in the end, and we are well on the road to a seasonal decline in inventory. 

Last year, according to Altos Research, the seasonal peak for housing inventory was Oct. 28. The seasonal peak this year was on Nov. 17.

  • Weekly inventory change: (Dec. 8-15): Inventory fell from 546,424 to 538,767
  • Same week last year (Dec. 9-16): Inventory fell from 536,409 to 522,869
  • The inventory bottom for 2022 was 240,194
  • The inventory peak for 2023 so far is 569,898
  • For context, active listings for this week in 2015 were 1,037,129

New listing data in 2023 has been a positive story; even with higher mortgage rates, we didn’t see more sellers pull back as they did in 2022 after rates surpassed 6%. Because we saw stability in 2023, I was looking for some flat to positive year-over-year growth in the data during the second half of the year. This is what we see, and it’s much needed; we need more new listings and not fewer. Even though this data line has been trending at the lowest levels ever in history for 17 months, it’s positive that we are seeing growth on a year-over-year basis now. This was something I talked about on CNBC months ago. 

New listings data for last week in the last several years:

  • 2023: 39,613
  • 2022: 34,973
  • 2021: 39,936

Traditionally, one-third of all homes will have price cuts before they sell. When mortgage rates rise and demand decreases, more homes see price cuts. However, even with mortgage rates reaching 8% this year, we trended below 2022 levels the entire time. Now that mortgage rates have fallen almost 1.5%, it will be interesting to see what the spring season in 2024 will look like. If demand does pick up as we are seeing now, the percentage of houses taking price cuts will likely fall further.

Price cut percentages this week over the last few years:

  • 2023: 38%
  • 2022: 41%
  • 2021: 26%

The week ahead: Housing and Inflation 

Housing week is here so we have four reports: the builders confidence Index, housing starts, existing home sales and new home sales. Also, we have the Fed’s critical inflation data report in the PCE, and it will be interesting to see how the bond market reacts to this report now that the Fed is discussing rate cuts. We also have the leading economic index to report on.

So, tons of data coming out this week. One thing about existing home sales: purchase application data started to improve five weeks ago. This data line looks out 30-90 days, so this existing home sales report might be too early to take into account the entire positive move in the forward-looking data.



Source link


A recession isn’t off the table for 2024, so you’ll need to know how to prepare for a recession and profit if the economy starts to slide. If your real estate values fall, your tenants stop paying rent, or you lose your job, how will you ensure you keep your properties? Those who can survive the bad times often thrive in the good—so what should you do to prepare?

Today, our expert panel gives four suggestions ANY investor can take to make it through a recession unscathed. All of these suggestions are being put into practice NOW by our panel of experts. They’re not complicated, and acting on even a few of them could save you tens of thousands (or an entire property) if and when a recession finally does hit.

From cutting costs to keeping cash on hand, investing differently, and building a “backup” for buying properties, these tactics will enable you to scoop up the deals that inexperienced investors couldn’t hold onto!

Dave:
Hey everyone, welcome to On The Market. I’m your host, Dave Meyer, and today we’re going to be talking about, God, the thing that we just keep talking about for the last three years straight. Is there going to be recession in 2024? Well, we’re just going to take the question out of it and pretend that there is going to be, and we’re going to give you some advice on how to recession proof your business in the case that there is a recession in 2024.
To help me with this, I have Henry Washington, Kathy Fettke and James Dainard joining me. Thank you three for joining us. I appreciate your time.

Kathy:
Thank you.

James:
I’m ready to talk about 2024. I’m done with 2023.

Dave:
You look tired, man. You look like 23 has worked a number on you.

James:
Yeah, the only good 23 is Michael Jordan. That’s about it.

Dave:
All right. Time to move on to 24.

Henry:
Kobe year.

Dave:
Yeah. Wait, was Kobe 24 first or was he eight first?

Henry:
He was eight first. Whoa. 2008 was the recession, so maybe Kobe 24 is the next recession. Boom!

Dave:
Oh, no. Well, I was just about to say that a bunch of economists have been saying that the chance of a recession in 2024 was less than 50%, but you know how there’s always those octopi that predict the Olympics better? So I think Henry’s random prediction about Kobe’s numbers is probably right. So anyway, the real predictions are something about 20% to 25% of a recession next year. That’s at least according to Treasury Secretary, Lawrence H. Summers, or former Treasury Secretary, or Yardeni Research, which is a real estate research company. They produce some really interesting data. They’re saying that there’s a 30% chance of a global recession, and so these people at least are not saying it’s the most probable outcome, but that is definitely more comfortable than most of us want to be.
And just for everyone to know, we talk about this a lot, but a recession doesn’t have any official meaning. I know a lot of people use the two consecutive quarters of GDP loss as the meaning, but it really is up to a bunch of academics and bureaucrats to decide whether or not a recession happens or not. So we don’t really know what’s going to happen and if it’s going to happen, but I think the important thing is that there’s risk in the market. There is a chance that there’s going to be a downturn in economic activity, and therefore we are going to discuss best practices for your business so that you can hopefully just be conservative and prepare in case something bad does happen. And if everything goes great, then you’re just in a better position anyway. So everyone has one piece of advice. James, Henry, Kathy, and I are each going to offer a piece of advice on how to recession proof your business. And Kathy, you have drawn the short straw and have to go first. So what do you got?

Kathy:
Well, I just first want to say that the economy is really pumping right now. It’s going to be a big GDP this quarter, so I’m not too worried about it happening right away, but there are some economists who think maybe mid next year, maybe in the fall. Either way, I look at my investments as if there’s going to be one. Why not? Be prepared for that, be prepared for if there’s not going to be one. And the way that I do that is either way, if there’s going to be a recession or not, I like to make sure I have plenty of cash reserves in place. Remember, I’m a buy and hold investor, which means that you buy it and then you have to hold it. There’s two pieces to the puzzle here. Right? And the way that people lose money in buy and hold, there’s several ways of course, but the big way, and certainly in 2008 is they couldn’t hold it. When those loans came due, they weren’t able to afford that payment.
That’s really not what people are facing today in buy and hold for the most part, at least in one to four, they’re mostly fixed rate loans. So just making sure you have plenty of cash reserves in case your tenant loses their job. Now, that can happen at any time because we’ve been living through a recession in certain industries. If you’re in real estate, if you’re a real estate agent or mortgage broker, you’ve been in a recession and there’s lots of them out there and they’re not making the money they used to make, generally.
So there’s always a risk that your tenant could lose their job, that they could get sick, that something could happen. And having that six months reserves, and what I mean by that is six months rent overhead. You just want to have that in a bank somewhere, so that that gives you plenty of time if your tenant loses their job and you need to cover the expenses. So that’s what I do anyway, and that makes me feel like I can walk into any economy and feel safe.

Dave:
Kathy, when you’re creating a cash reserve, do you basically just hold back cashflow until you have six months? Or what about people who might not have six months of cash reserves currently? Do you recommend they inject capital into an operating account, or how do they do that tactically?

Kathy:
Personally, what I advise people is have it at the outset. You know you’ve got it. Now, if you are just starting out and you don’t have that capital, then you would just keep all the cashflow, everything that comes in, it just goes into an account and you don’t touch it. And that’s your reserve account because remember, it’s buy an old real estate, people live in your property. If there’re going to be repairs, you need that reserve anyway. So just have it, six months reserves for rents and overhead, general overhead, but also a cushion for repairs. You should know your property well enough to know how old certain items are, have they been replaced? When will they need to be replaced? What’s the CapEx that you’re looking at? And have that set aside too.
Maybe you could put them in a two or three month CD or something, make a little money on it while it’s sitting there. It doesn’t have to sit in a non-interest bearing account, but just it needs to be somewhat accessible, especially if you’re in California or in a state where it’s harder to evict. Where we invest, if somebody loses their job and we have to evict, then it can be just a matter of weeks for that to happen. But in certain non-landlord friendly places like California, it could be six months, it could be a year. So anyway, yeah, if you’re in California, then maybe you want 12 months reserves.

Dave:
That’s a great point. I think it really does depend on the individual property and your individual circumstances. Six months is a rule of thumb, but if you know that your hot water heater’s rusting out and about to pop at any point, you might want that well, or if your tenants have a history of making late payments, you might want to consider that as well.

James:
Yeah, and it depends on what kind of assets that you’re in. I love what Kathy said because that’s that old mindset of that historical kind of metrics of keeping six months aside, and I love that. I think after 2008, I really learned that lesson and really started keeping. I call it my oh, curse word money. It’s got to be sitting over there. The thing is, with how things have moved over the last couple of years and how people have gotten into growth, it’s not just the traditional six months aside. You really got to get into the forecasting of what your businesses are and what they’re doing, and then make adjustments for what’s essential in today’s market. If you’re only looking at performers and P&Ls, it doesn’t tell you where your capital’s getting eroded.
And so you’ve got to spend a lot of time forecasting that cashflow out, putting it aside, making sure you have your reserves and then making your adjustments. Because as we go through transitions, you have to adjust those models.

Henry:
Yeah, I agree. James. One of the things we like to do is to have a set amount per number of doors. So meaning if you’ve got five doors, then maybe we’d like to have somewhere between 10 and 30 grand in an account. The most expensive thing typically from a maintenance perspective or CapEx perspective that we’d have to put on a house is probably a new roof. And so just making sure that if something happens, we’ve got to put a new roof on a property that the money’s there to be able to do that. And then as the portfolio grows, then that amount of savings needs to increase with it. And then as we spend that money, we’ve got to reduce cashflow spending and make sure that cashflow goes back into that account to make sure we just keep those amounts to make it just a little easier to manage. But first and foremost, Dave, if you’ve got a hot water heater that’s about to pop, just go ahead and replace that.

Dave:
Yeah, just replace it.

Henry:
Speaking from experience because I’m buying a house right now that the seller didn’t do that. The whole house flooded and now he’s stuck and then they found asbestos and now his house is down to the studs. So just go ahead and replace [inaudible 00:08:52].

Kathy:
Just get it done.

Dave:
Just go ahead and do it. That’s not cash reserve, that’s just repairs.

Kathy:
I like to buy stuff that is either new as you guys know or is repaired on the outset because then you can gauge your capital expense a little bit better. You know what you’re in for if everything’s fairly new.

Dave:
Henry, I was going to ask you, if you own a bunch of properties, do you have cash reserve on every property level or do you ever just do it as a portfolio level, sort of like the insurance model, the likelihood that you’re going to have an event in every property is low, so you can leave less total reserve as long as you’re thinking about the total portfolio?

Henry:
Yeah, we do it in buckets. So every five properties, we want to have X amount of X money in reserves. So if I have 10 properties and I know that’s X amount of dollars. If I have 11, we still keep it at that number, but once we get to 15, then we increase it again.

Dave:
Is that how you do it too, James?

James:
Yeah. Well, it depends on the business. Typically, with our portfolio, cashflow is pretty heavy right now. And so we don’t take a dollar from our cashflow throughout the year, and then at the end we then reallocate it out. So our portfolio really does pay for itself 3X over, but we had to get there. And so yes, right now we would put money aside and then it’s to cover, if we weren’t at our cash flows, we would have at minimum six months of payments. Plus, we like to have a maintenance account that’s typically going to be about 1% of our net cash flows.

Dave:
Well, Kathy, thank you. Very, very good advice just as reminders to build a cash reserve and really safeguard that cashflow. Henry, what’s your advice for recession proofing your business next year?

Henry:
So this is what helps people start to build that cash reserve, but I think we need to pay attention to what’s it costing us to operate our business? And this one is the hidden killer because these costs sometimes feel like they’re coming out of nowhere because you’re getting so many little onesie, twosie things that happen in your business that in the moment don’t seem like it’s a big deal. And then you look back at the end of the year or at the end of the month when you’re doing your bookkeeping and you’re like, “Holy crap, how much did I spend on X, Y, Z maintenance?” For me right now, I was getting eaten up by all of these little pieces of software that we need in different parts of our business.

Dave:
It’s like subscriptions.

Henry:
Yeah, subscriptions. But it’s like I’ve got a tool for this social media thing and I got a tool for this part of my business where we’re looking at offers and there’s all these little tools and subscriptions and you forget sometimes that you sign up for them and it’s just like people with their cable bills and all that. You’re looking at them, but you need to do that in your business too because as we’ve been growing, we find these tools, we use these tools and some of them are great, but now we’ve been spending a lot… I’ve been spending a lot of time looking at them, scaling them back and then consolidating them into one singular tool that does everything. And I’ve probably saved myself five grand a month just in the cost of some of these tools that we’re using elsewhere in our business.
So it’s about tracking your expenses and being more diligent about tracking expenses and understanding where you’re spending the money and do you need to continue spending that money? Can you consolidate some of these services? Can you hire someone to eliminate some of these things? A lot of the times it’s just… I guess the goal is you want to take a look at what are your expenses in your business? What are you truly spending money on every month? And making sure A, that you truly need to be spending that money or B, can you make a decision to bring somebody on or bring on a tool that eliminates you having to spend that money? Sometimes you can find a lot of your savings to help you save up for that cash reserve Kathy was talking about right now in what you’re currently spending in your business.

Kathy:
Oh my gosh, I agree so much. When times are good and when times are great like they have been the past 10 years, people are going hard, they’re going fast, they’re making a lot of money, they’re not really paying attention to expenses. A lot of times they’re just going and at times like this, you get to slow down and look at operations and really cut back because I think a lot of excess happens during the good years and it’s fun.
Anyway, so I know that with our team, it’s like everybody goes through, looks at the extra expenses that we maybe took on but don’t actually need. And sometimes, unfortunately, that can be personnel as well. If you had to hire extra people during the good times, they maybe have to go during the slower times, but this is the time to really just slow down and look at overall expenses and what’s truly needed and what could be cut.

James:
Yeah, it was funny. I was just talking to my wife the other day. I’m like, “Hey, we’re going to do a credit card, debit card purge. We’re going to cancel every debit card and credit card and then we’ll see what bills come in and go, ‘Hey, you need to renew or update your payment.’ If we don’t want it, we’re just going to cancel it right then because once it pings for the auto-renewal…” But yeah, these little costs can really erode your business and something else to think about that we’ve been really looking at is operational costs. For us as investors, I look at money as inventory for us. It’s inventory that we use to grow our business and our portfolio and buy new things and we have money sitting there, we want to deploy it and we want to get into the next deal.
But then sometimes as deal junkies and investors, you’re not thinking about, “Okay, well now I got to really secure this property. I got the dead time. I got insurance costs. I got these little creeping bills that don’t seem like much when you’re just racking deals,” but if you’ve got to pay four more insurance premiums, why it’s sitting and being turned, or you got to pay four more superintendents to manage your properties, why it’s being turned, those are the costs that are really eroding.
And so you have to work that all into that and go, “How do I reduce that and change that up in times when cash flows are lower?” Like for us, we got rid of some of our project managers because that’s a dead salary of a hundred grand a year. And it was not a dead salary, it’s to operate, but we have to pay for that. And we started structuring deals differently and bringing in partners and slicing in the deal to erode our monthly payment on that, and we’re still getting the projects done.
So it’s about looking at the business and go, “How do I reduce my costs?” And whether it’s through partnerships, cutting the cost, cutting waste, but we all have to do that right now. Cut the cost one way, shape or form and restructure it.

Dave:
Do you have Henry, any advice on how to go about doing this? Should you perhaps buy some new software subscription that will help you figure out what software subscriptions you don’t need?

Henry:
Yes, absolutely. In order to figure out how not to pay for stuff, you should go pay for something.

Dave:
You know there is actually a tool that you pay for that stops your subscription? It’s a subscription to stop your subscription.

Henry:
Yes.

Kathy:
It works. You sign up for things you forgot.

Dave:
That’s a good idea actually.

Henry:
First of all, within your business, you should be doing bookkeeping. And if you’re doing bookkeeping, you should already have an accounting of what you’re spending every month and on what those things are for. So really, it’s just diving into your monthly bookkeeping and seeing where your money is going and then get to that kind of micro level and then make decisions on, “Do I need to be spending this money on this thing right now or is this something that I can do either on my own?” Maybe it’s that you take a set of services that you’re paying for and then you hire a VA to take care of doing those tasks. And sometimes that VA cost will be a lot cheaper and more efficient than you paying for multiple different pieces of software that take care of those things.
So there’s tons of ways you can look at it, but I’d start with your bookkeeping. If you don’t have a bookkeeper, then A, you probably either need to go hire one or B, get one of these free tools that will categorize your expenses for you like I think Mint, but I think they just might’ve gone out of business, but there’s a few free tools that you can use.

Dave:
Yeah, yeah, there totally are. I think a lot of banks actually do it. I know Chase does it, and even if you do your bookkeeping yourself, like QuickBooks Online for example, they have some auto categorization features that you can use that are actually really helpful. It’s not perfect. It’s not the same as having a bookkeeper, but even just for most rental properties, I don’t know about you guys, but for an individual rental properties, there aren’t that many expenses. It doesn’t take that long to go through, especially the recurring ones, unless you’re doing a rehab or anything. The recurring ones, go see what’s on there. It’s not that hard to just even eyeball it.

Kathy:
You got to know your numbers, you got to know your numbers, especially at times like this and be looking at expenses every week at least, at least. What am I spending money on? Where is it coming from? Where is it going? And if you aren’t completely dialed in, then you’re either leaving money on the table, you’re just spending too much. It’s like that is the job of a business owner is to know your numbers inside and out.

Dave:
Well said. All right, James, for our third piece of advice for recession proofing your business, as a reminder, Kathy said to build cash reserve, safeguard your cashflow. Henry said to reduce and evaluate operating costs. James, what’s your advice?

James:
It’s all about having access to capital. As we’ve gone into a transitionary market, what’s happened is a lot of investors, including ourselves, you perform at a deal, the debt has changed and you’ve had to service that debt cost. And some of these projects that can take six, 12 months, 18 months, when your rate jumps from 9% to 11% or even 8% to 11%, it erodes your capital back. And so what we’ve had to do is we’ve had to really get comfortable with securing other types of backup slush fund credit, and that’s by working with banks and getting access to capital and working with banks to help you with these cashflow issues. Every deal that we’re looking at right now, we are talking to our lenders and going, “Hey, how do we get a 12 to 18 month interest reserve put in this deal?” And an interest reserve is where they finance in all of your carry costs so you can really function off the now and not worry about the debt cost creeping up on you on a 12 to 18 month period.
And so what we found is we wanted to build better relationships with banks so we can structure deals a little bit better. By us moving over deposits to a bank, they’re paying us a 4.5% return, which is great. It’s not what we make us as investors, but we’re moving our money over, which then by moving the money over, we’re making a 4.5% return. We’re borrowing the money then on a deal at 9%, 10%, but then they’ll factor in all of our cashflow needs, which is going to be those interest reserves that carry costs and stuff that you need to push through a flatter market.
And so by really working with banks and getting these lines together, it gives you these levers that you need to push you through a hump. Every time an investor buys a deal, it takes up capital. You got to put your down payment down, you got to service the debt, you got to service the people to facilitate the transaction, and that’s where you can get in trouble. And as investors, the thing with us, as soon as money comes back in our bank account, what do we want to do? We want to go do the next deal.
And so you get these wins, you race into the next deal, but then you’re not forecasting that hard six to 12 month cashflow. So by having your banks and your slush sum reserves, that’s what’s really going to push you through the humps. And that’s about getting personal line of credits. Having access to credit card debt, even though I don’t really believe in it, it’s way too expensive. I don’t think you should be doing deals if you’re going on credit cards right now, personally, but that’s just for me.
And then also moving your money to smaller portfolio banks that will look at you as far as a business, not just a client in the bank. When you meet with these portfolio banks, they look at your forecasting in your businesses and they’re going to structure your debt around that. They look at our performance, they look at our assets, they look how we’re going to stabilize things. If I go to one of the big banks, all it is, “How many deposits do you have? What’s your monthly expenses? We’re going to give you that leverage on that.” So by moving around to small business banks, it’s really helped give us access to debt, but they also understand the business for better terms.

Henry:
Yeah, I think this is fantastic because this is something I wholeheartedly agree with. I think what you want is access to capital in the event that you need it, right? Yes, recessions are difficult times, but recessions also create opportunities for investors and opportunities to buy, and access to money is just harder right now. And so you don’t want to miss out on an amazing opportunity because you haven’t prepared yourself on the front side to have access to capital to be able to jump on it. And so we’re not saying go rack up a bunch of debt for no reason. We’re saying prepare yourself, have access to capital and then use it strategically. And so being able to do something like… Everybody has a bank account. And so if you’ve got a bank account, even if it’s not at a small local bank, you can probably call your bank and see if they’ll just give you access to an unsecured line of credit. That’s kind of a cheat code nobody knows about.
So an unsecured line of credit is essentially a line of credit. So the bank will extend you a line of credit just based on they like you. It’s not secured by any asset. So secured lines of credit are things we’re all used to, like a home equity line of credit, that’s a line of credit that’s secured by a piece of property. You can secure loans with all types of collateral depending on how cool that bank wants to be with what they want to consider collateral. But mostly, you’re going to get a line of credit secured by a piece of property or you’re going to get a line of credit secured by your credit worthiness. And that’s all an unsecured line of credit is. It’s them saying, “We like you, we like your credit score. Here’s some money that we’ll allow you to use.”

Dave:
And if you’re unfamiliar with a line of credit in general, it’s basically just money that you can use but you don’t have to use. It’s similar to a credit card basically. It’s available to you. The bank issues you a credit limit and you can take out part of it, all of it. So if you had $100,000 as your line of credit, you could take out $10,000 and just pay on the $10,000. You’re not paying on the full amount of your credit limit.

Henry:
They already bank with you that you already got money in there in deposits. They have a relationship with you. You can call down there and say, “What would you give me an unsecured line of credit for?” And they may just turn around and give you access to some money that you can use for a down payment for the next good deal that comes your way. Now, you don’t want to over-leverage yourself and spend that on a bad deal, but just having that as a backup plan to be able to know, “Hey, if a good deal comes my way, I just got 20 grand on an unsecured line of credit with this bank.” And you don’t have to use the money. And if you don’t use the money, then you’re not paying any interest on it. So there’s lots of good little things you can do like that to be better prepared, better capitalized for opportunities coming your way through a recession.

Kathy:
Yeah, it’s a conundrum, right? At times like this, as the Federal Reserve is trying to pull money out of the system, they flooded the system with money over COVID. And the many years prior to that, it was easy to get access to money. And the process over the last 18 months is to pull that money back out. And during times like that, it’s harder to get money, but at the same time, that’s when the deals are there. So you’ve got to get good at finding money in any kind of market, but definitely in the coming market because it is harder to get, which means there’ll be less competition, which means there’ll be more deals and you’re the one who gets those deals if you can find the money. And there’s so many ways to do it. It doesn’t have to be just through a bank.

Dave:
Yeah, this makes so much sense right now. It always makes sense, but we’re in this weird scenario where prices might fall a little bit. We are seeing some downward pressure, but it’s also still very competitive to buy, which is just this confounding dynamic that doesn’t actually make any sense, but it’s reality. And so like Henry said, and like everyone said, you have to just be ready to jump on these opportunities because there are going to be ones, but they’re going to go really quickly. It’s not going to be the kind of recession, at least in my mind, where deals are sitting on the market for 180 days and you’re going to have your time. Things will come up and opportunities will arise, but people are going to be waiting and you should be one of them.

James:
And I think that’s why it’s so important to have your cashflow forecasted out in a six to 12 month period because you can get blinded by the good deal and just go get it, but then all of a sudden you’re in quicksand because you have to keep up with that debt. And so really forecast that cashflow out and know even if you have a good deal, sometimes the best deal you ever do is passing on that deal. And so forecast and make sure that you can keep up with it and have your slush fund because that’s where the quicksand starts.

Dave:
All right. So far, we have three excellent pieces of advice, which is to build your cash reserve, reduce and evaluate operating costs and secure financing before you need it. The last one I’ll bring, which I can feel you guys rolling your eyes already, which is to diversify your investments. I know none of the three of you diversify outside of real estates, but I do. I like to keep at least some of my net worth in stocks and bonds and bonds and money market accounts are doing pretty well right now. You can earn about 5%, 5.5%. And I think the real thing that I focus on in these types of markets is actually just trying to balance liquidity. It’s not even necessarily trying to get into multiple different types of assets, but it’s making sure that if I need a big amount of money that I can get it.
And real estate has many benefits. Liquidity is not necessarily one of them. If you’re unfamiliar with this term, liquidity is basically how quickly you can turn an asset, which is anything that has value, into cash, and it’s relative what you mean. I generally think it’s can you turn something to cash into a week, in two weeks, in three weeks? And so there’s this big spectrum. Cash is obviously the most valuable because you can use it and it’s the most liquid. On the far end of the spectrum, it’s like fine wines and art. And real estate is on the further end of that spectrum where it’s relatively illiquid, which is fine because most of us buy and hold for long periods of time. But during periods where there is a lot of volatility, particularly if your job or your income is volatile, I think it’s really important to balance your portfolio and your investments to make sure that you always have access to… You could sell something, you could sell your stocks, you can sell your bonds in case you needed to cover something in your real estate portfolio.
So generally, that’s just how I think about things. It’s just basically trying to make sure that I always have options to liquidate some part of my investment portfolio if an emergency occurs. Now, I choose to do that across different asset classes. I know you all don’t, but you can also diversify within real estate as well. So in addition to owning rental properties, for example, which typically have a very long hold period, you could also flip houses or you can wholesale or you can hotel because that you just have your money into those investments for less time. And so you have more frequent opportunities to reallocate your capital in these changing market conditions. What happens three or six months from now might be very different from what’s happening today. And so if you do a flip and you get your money out in six months, you have that chance to take advantage of whatever’s doing best then, whereas some of the longer term holds aren’t necessarily as good for that.
So that’s generally my advice is to try and make sure that you have liquidity across your entire portfolio. Now Kathy, I know you have almost all your money in real estate and you’re mostly a buy and hold investor. So how do you think about this? Do you have any more liquid assets in your portfolio?

Kathy:
Yeah, we invest in gold. Rich does play a little bit in the stock market mostly for fun and to learn it and cash. So yes, I’ll call that diversification.

Dave:
So mostly cash. Cash is the most liquid thing there is. It doesn’t take any time to turn cash to cash.

Kathy:
Yeah.

Dave:
Okay. So I like it. Okay. So Henry, I know you mostly invest in real estate and that’s totally fine. So within real estate, how do you think about how you allocate your money? Do you think that, “Oh, I’m going to do some long-term investments, some short-term investments,” or how do you manage your equity and your capital in a way to mitigate risk?

Henry:
Yeah, no, that’s a great question. So for me, obviously my main strategy is buy and hold. And so that is where obviously the bulk of the net worth comes in. But I like doing flips as a way to generate capital. And I will also look at my portfolio as a whole, as my rental portfolio as a whole and determine which of these rental properties can I monetize sooner than later when it’s financially beneficial to do so? Because markets are cyclical. So I may have properties that I bought as a buy and hold, but maybe that property is way more capital intensive because of the… Maybe it’s way more maintenance intensive than I was expecting or that I underwrote that deal for. And if the market is up, I can probably get paid a hefty premium for selling that property, eliminating the maintenance expense, which was eating away at the cashflow, and then make so much profit that it would’ve taken me a decade or two decades to generate that kind of cash from just the cashflow month over month, especially because the maintenance was eating away at it.
So I try to look at, A, evaluate my portfolio as a whole and see how I can monetize things differently in order to increase cash in my business. But yeah, I’m always looking at how can I generate capital on a short-term and then how can I offset those gains when you’re flipping through holding the real estate.

Dave:
Thank you. Yeah, that makes a ton of sense. Just trying to mix the different types of investments and the different kinds of wins. James, you talked a little bit about forecasting your cash flow. Is this something that you do as well, doing as many flips? How do you make sure that you’re scheduling your deals so that you get regular injections of capital back and you’re not having too much of your capital invested into long-term things?

James:
Yeah, and I love this topic. It’s funny, a lot of times people will talk to me and they say, “Hey, you’re not diversified, you’re only in real estate.” But I look at my portfolio as being a pie chart with diversification that we’re moving around at all given times. In today’s market, we know access to capital is essential. And so I have really allocated probably 50% of my cash into private lending where they’re on three to six nine month notes that pay me a much higher yield than when I have to pay for my bank financing all my other deals for. So I know that the cashflow for my private money lending is going to pay for any debt that I’m securing on any kind of short-term investment engine or rental property that’s on a negative to offset that. So I look at every market that I expand the pie charts.
Two years ago when rates were really low, I would say I had 50% of my capital in short-term high yield investments, which was fix and flip and development. And so as the market gets riskier and things get flatter, we just move things around. Like right now, I don’t want to trap any money in a deal that’s going to pay me an average return, even if it’s a great rental property. If I can structure it right with leverage to where I don’t have to leave much in, then I’ll look at that deal. But I don’t want to go leave 20% in to get a growth factor over a five to 10 year period because what we’ve referenced on the show is there is some amazing deals that pop up right now.
And so I like to have my cash in a high yield investment that I have access to liquidity for. I can make a move, buy that deal if I need to, but I’m going to be heavier on that passive income streams with access to capital. And I think that’s just important to move things around as you grow, but it also depends on where you’re at in your investing career. When I was newer in 2008, 2009 and 2010, we did not do that. It was about pushing through and growing. And so depending on where you want to be, you want to look at where’s the portfolio, what are my goals? And then set your pie chart.
It’s no different than those financial planners. I have a pie chart for my liquidity and my investments, where’s it going to allocate? And based on my goals, it’s going to tell me what to do in my pie chart. So I’m not in as high growth factors as I used to be, so I’m going to be a little bit lower returns with more cash accessible. If I’m making 12% of my money with private money, that’s making about one third of what I would make flipping a house on a return basis, but it gives me access to capital, it pays for other debts and it allows things to move things around. So we’re constantly, every year I’m reshaping my pie chart, but this year I moved a lot into private. I wanted high yield cash accessible investments.

Dave:
That makes a lot of sense. And yeah, I just think this whole concept of what James is talking about, like reallocating capital within your portfolio is something not talked about enough in real estate. I think there’s some mantras where it’s like just buy and hold on forever, but even if you’re a buy and hold investor, you should still be thinking about selling properties and buying new buy and hold properties just and optimizing, as you said James, your pie chart based on current market conditions and what else you can get out there. So in addition to diversification, just thinking about reallocating your capital to maybe safer investments is another… Maybe that’s the bonus tip for recession proofing your business right now is consider reallocating some capital into something safer.
All right, well, thank you guys so much. This was great help. I also want to recommend that if anyone wants additional advice on top of what James, Henry, Kathy, and I said today, BiggerPockets has a great book. It is called Recession-Proof Real Estate Investing. It’s written by J. Scott, my co-author of one of the books I wrote, and just a great real estate investor in general. It is full of really helpful practical tips on how to navigate any type of recession or economic downturn as a real estate investor. It’s really actually quite easy to read. I’ve read it like three, four different times and you can get through it in like two or three hours. Highly recommend.
All right, well, that’s it. Well, Kathy, James, Henry, thank you for joining us and thank you all for listening. We’ll see you for the next episode of On The Market. On The Market was created by me, Dave Meyer and Kailyn Bennett. The show is produced by Kailyn Bennett, with editing by Exodus Media. Copywriting is by Calico Content, and we want to extend a big thank you to everyone at BiggerPockets for making this show possible.

 

Help us reach new listeners on iTunes by leaving us a rating and review! It takes just 30 seconds and instructions can be found here. Thanks! We really appreciate it!

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email [email protected].

Note By BiggerPockets: These are opinions written by the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of BiggerPockets.



Source link


The housing market cheered as the Federal Reserve signaled interest rate cuts next year after making a series of rapid rate hikes starting in 2022. 

While the central bank did not completely rule out the possibility of a rate increase in 2024, that action seems unlikely. Instead, fresh economic projections from central bank officials showed rates would be slashed to a median 4.6% by the end of 2024, suggesting three 25 basis points (bps) cuts from current levels.

The so-called dot plot estimates show interest rates falling to a median 3.6% in 2025, indicating four more 25 bps cuts. For 2026, Fed officials projected rates to fall below 3% by the end of 2026 through three more quarter percentage point reductions. 

What does this mean for mortgage rates?

“Mortgage rates should get better. If the spreads get better, that will be an extra plus,” said Logan Mohtashami, lead analyst at HousingWire. “The main focus now is that if the economic data gets weaker, bond traders have the green light to take yields lower.”

Mortgage rates track the yield on 10-year U.S. Treasuries, which move based on anticipation about the Fed’s actions, what the Fed ends up doing and investors’ reactions. When Treasury yields go down, so do mortgage rates. The 10-year Treasury yield hit a low of 4.007% following the Fed’s press conference, declining from 4.202% at market open on Wednesday.

“While nobody in the mortgage world would say ’tis the season to be jolly’ based on current market conditions, the Fed’s outlook at its December meeting points to an increased possibility of a happier new year,” said Marty Green, principal at mortgage law firm Polunsky Beitel Green.

Expect lower mortgage rates

With the central bank shifting toward the next phase in its fight against rapid inflation, experts expect the path for monetary policy to support further declines in mortgage rates, just in time for a traditionally busy spring housing market.

“The commentary about three expected cuts next year and no rate hikes is great news for the mortgage industry,” Michael Merritt, senior vice president of customer care and default mortgage servicing at BOK Financial. “These cuts will allow mortgage rates to fall faster throughout 2024. The conservative expectation of three cuts also paints a positive overall outlook since they are not expecting to have to make large numbers of cuts to fuel economic growth or make increases to offset inflation.”

After hovering below 8% at the time of the last FOMC meeting in November, mortgage rates sit at just under 7%, according to HousingWire’s mortgage rate center on Wednesday.

“We’re probably at an inflection point where rates have come down enough that more buyers are coming back into the marketplace,” said Melissa Cohn, regional vice president of William Raveis Mortgage.

While mortgage rates are expected to decrease, high home prices combined with low inventory still pose a challenge for potential homebuyers.

“We don’t expect rates to fall that much in this period and it may not offset rising home prices in hot housing markets. So, homebuyers who wait on the sidelines for better rates next year may find the waiting game didn’t pay the dividends they expected,” said Max Slyusarchuk, CEO of A&D Mortgage.

The median price of single family homes in the U.S. is $424,900, which is up 2.4% from last year at the same time, according to Altos Research.

“There are really no national indicators, anywhere in the data, that show home prices currently falling,” Mike Simonsen, president of Altos, said in a recent commentary.

While inventory typically rises with higher mortgage rates and falls with lower mortgage rates, there is no signal of any flood of sellers, which would be bearish for home prices, Simonsen noted. 

For there to be a supply-demand balance, rates would need to stay higher and cuts would have to come slower than markets are predicting, according to Jack Macdowell, chief investment officer at Palisades Group.

“The housing market plays a role in this given the contribution to headline inflation calculations,” Macdowell said.

“If rates come down too much (and mortgage rates follow), we’ll see the current supply-demand imbalance exacerbated as pent-up demand gets released into an undersupplied market, putting upward pressure on home values–and inflation. Until mortgage rates drop below 6% it is unlikely that pent-up deferred sales will meaningfully contribute to supply.”



Source link


Top U.S. mortgage lender United Wholesale Mortgage (UWM) is offering discounted rates on some government loans until January for brokers to create their own “refi boom,” the company announced on Wednesday. 

The initiative includes three new exclusive rates – 5.749% paying 1.5 points, 5.999% paying 2 points and 6.249% paying 2.5 points – on FHA and VA refinances available to brokers until Jan. 31, 2024. Borrowers must have at least 210 days from the first payment due date. 

To compare, at HousingWire’s Mortgage Rates Center, Optimal Blue’s data showed a 30-year fixed conforming mortgage rate at 6.978% on Tuesday. FHA rates were at 6.759% and rates for jumbo loans were even higher, at 7.333%. 

The UWM’s discounted rates apply to the FHA Streamline program, which offers a simplified refinance process with reduced documentation requirements on Federal Housing Administration (FHA) loans. It also includes VA Interest Rate Reduction Refinance Loans, which allows veterans to refinance their Department of Veteran Affairs (VA) loans at a lower rate without needing an appraisal or income verification. 

Mat Ishbia, president and CEO at UWM, said the company is giving brokers “the opportunity to create their own refinance boom for their FHA and VA borrowers.” 

“No other lender can match this offering, and with VA IRRRL and FHA Streamline loans being so quick and easy to close, this is the perfect opportunity to help borrowers lower their monthly payment while also showcasing the elite service an independent mortgage broker can provide through their partnership with UWM.”  

Top wholesale lenders have launched new initiatives to boost production at the end of 2023.

Rocket Pro TPO, the wholesale arm of Rocket Mortgage, announced in late November a credit of 25 basis points to the loan level pricing adjustment (LLPA) on agency mortgages for non-owner-occupied homes. 

“This is a huge win for any brokers who have clients shopping for a second home or an investment property or even those who want to take some cash out of one of their properties that has grown in value over the last few years,” Mike Fawaz, executive vice president at Rocket Pro TPO, said in an emailed response to HousingWire.  

Rocket Pro TPO kicked off an initiative on Dec. 1 called “December to Remember,” with offerings for broker partners to help them “finish the year strong,” Fawaz said. 



Source link


As 2023 winds to a close, so too does a brutal year for the housing market, a year marked by rising rates, steep home prices, scarce inventory and anemic mortgage originations, compared with the boom years of 2020 and 2021.

It also has been a brutal year for the secondary market that creates liquidity for mortgage lenders as greatly reduced mortgage originations, liquidity challenges and interest rate volatility have played havoc in the whole-loan trading as well as the private-label and agency securitization channels

“The market progressively got worse around the start July of 2022 and then throughout the course of 2023, driven by the Federal Reserve raising rates and the lack of liquidity in the banking sector,” said John Toohig, head of whole-loan trading on the Raymond James whole-loan desk and president of Raymond James Mortgage Co. “With first-lien mortgages … the trading volumes are down from 2021 and 2022 peak levels. 

“That’s largely due to the rapid change in rates, which are causing loans to trade at fairly steep discounts, and not due to credit performance. It’s purely driven by interest rate risk, and it’s also being driven by a lack of liquidity and a loss of deposits in the banking system [a major purchaser of whole loans and mortgage-backed securities in the past].”

Interest-rate and liquidity challenges also negatively impacted the agency (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae) mortgage-backed securities (MBS) market in 2023.

A recent report from real estate investment firm The Amherst Group forecasts that the combined net issuance of agency MBS is projected at $250 billion for 2023, compared with $530 billion last year. Those figures reflect a substantial reduction in new and existing-home sales and refinancing as interest rates ballooned past 7% over the period, driven by the Federal Reserve’s aggressive monetary-tightening policy.

By comparison, agency net MBS issuance in 2021, when interest rates were half of what they are today, came in at $870 billion, according to Amherst. Net issuance in MBS represents new securities issued less the decline in outstanding securities due to principal paydowns or prepayments.

Spread expansion

Adding to the woes in the agency MBS market are outsized spreads, with the spread between the 30-year fixed mortgage and the benchmark 10-year Treasury hovering around 2.9 percentage points in early December, when historically that spread has ranged between 1 to 2 percentage points. That wide spread has squeezed margins on agency MBS, with 6% coupons at yearend 2023, for example, trading at a fraction of a percentage point above par, down from nearly 10 points above par at the end of the first quarter of last year.

Amherst Chairman and CEO Sean Dobson said the shrinking margins in the agency MBS sector are a byproduct of an over-supply of paper and a greatly reduced investor balance sheets for absorbing the debt. A major purchaser of agency MBS until last year was the Federal Reserve, he explained, which is now allowing up to $35 billion of MBS to roll off its balance sheet each month.

The reduced role of the Fed and other investors in the agency MBS market is acting as a type of governor on rates, preventing them from getting much downward traction. As origination volume increases, and related MBS issuance goes up, so does the supply of MBS for sale in the market — creating downward pressure on prices, assuming buyer demand remains repressed.

Andrew Rhodes, senior director and head of trading at Mortgage Capital Trading, said a loan originator is trying to estimate where their end investor is going to be buying the loan, “so whether it’s the whole loan or the securitization, they are trying to figure out exactly what that price is going to be.” 

“Then the independent mortgage bank (IMB) can originate the loan to that level because that’s how they’re really managing that margin,” he added. “And if all of a sudden, your investor that you thought was going to be spending 103 or 104 [for that loan or MBS] is now at 102, that’s a big hit to that origination volume that you thought was going to be getting a point or two higher in price.”

Dobson said heading into the end of 2023, the securitization market “is structurally impaired right now because the normal sponsor [investor] base is absent.” 

“Some of them are gone forever, and some of them are basically going to have to rebuild capability,” he said. “…This is speculative to a certain extent, but should rates go down, and should a lot of [new MBS] supply get created because of refinancing activity, the market is going to have a really hard time with that. 

“…So, now the question is, what’s the new level that gets it [MBS] to clear when the normal sponsors [investors, such as the Fed] are offline, and that new level is an excess return that’s now something like 50 basis points wider than corporate bonds.”

Amherst projects that in 2023, the pull-back of the Federal Reserve as well as the banking sector from the agency MBS market will result in a combined $425 billion in excess MBS that will need to be absorbed by other investors, such as money managers and foreign investors.

“I think the Fed will not sell MBS but rather is prepared to keep letting the portfolio run off, even if they start cutting rates,” said Richard Koss, chief research officer at mortgage-data analytics firm Recursion.

 “The Central Bank has expressed its interest in reducing its role in the mortgage market and would rather cut rates more if needed, rather than slow down the process of reducing its holdings of MBS,” Koss added.

Bank contraction

In addition to the reduced role of the Fed in the MBS market, the banking industry and other investors also have pulled back from MBS purchases in the wake of financial pressures sparked by rising rates — as well as plans by regulators to tighten bank capital-reserve rules. 

“The problem is … the benchmark of fair [MBS] value was set when the GSEs [government-sponsored enterprises, Fannie and Freddie] could buy [MBS], when the banks could run huge balance sheets, when the REITs [real estate investment trusts] could run big balance sheets, and when the regional banking system wasn’t [impaired],” Dobson said.

Over the past year, a number of large banks have collapsed — among them Silicon Valley BankSignature BankFirst Republic Bank and Signature Bank.

“I think there are seven or eight banks total that exited warehouse lending this year, [such as Comerica and First Third Bank],” said Charley Clark, a senior vice president and mortgage warehouse finance executive at EverBank (formerly known as TIAA Bank). The unit does warehouse and MSR lending “and really anything that relates to lending to IMBs [independent mortgage banks],” according to Clark.

The top 15 warehouse lenders as of the end of the third quarter of this year had extended nearly $80 billion in warehouse line commitments, representing about 80% of the market, according to an Inside Mortgage Finance report.

“We were not part of this, but there were definitely funding and liquidity issues [for banks this year], not only just liquidity issues in general, but the cost of funding on the margin,” he added. “So, it was not only hard to find deposits, but they’re expensive. 

“And if you look at something like warehouse lending [to IMBs], the spreads are very tight. If you’re a bank that’s having liquidity and funding issues, what are you going to cut? You’re going to go to the lower spreads to cut, right?”

Other sectors

The narrative is similar for the private-label residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) market. 

A yearend forecast report by the Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA) projects that RMBS issuance in 2023 will come in at about $52 billion, down nearly 50% from 2022 and $10 billion below KBRA’s original projection for the year issued in November 2022. KBRA includes prime, nonprime, credit-risk transfer transactions and second-lien offerings in its RMBS analysis.

“[Reduced] mortgage volumes and continued spread volatility in a rising rate environment contributed to a meaningful issuance decline [in 2023],” KBRA’s recent forecast report states.

Ben Hunsaker, portfolio manager focused on securitized credit for Beach Point Capital Management, said for real growth in the housing market to occur, mortgage originations need to increase substantially along with higher securitization volumes, “and it doesn’t seem like that’s highly likely right now.”

“In the case where the Fed cuts [the benchmark rate by] 250 basis points, I’m not sure that’s necessarily a scenario where housing volumes are great and housing prices are strong because that would probably be pretty correlated with a really weak consumer or some recessionary-type outcome,” he added. “And then you have to have wider spreads [due to increased risk], which means the value of creating those mortgages and securitizing them is again hampered.”

If there was one bright spot in the secondary market in 2023, it was the mortgage-servicing rights (MSR) sector, which performs better in rising-rate environments because mortgage prepayment speeds slow to very low levels and returns from parked escrow deposits also rise — both of which help to pump up the value of MSRs. Trading volume in the MSR sector in 2023 is on track to slightly exceed 2022’s $1.1 trillion mark, according to Tom Piercy, chief growth officer at Incenter Capital Advisors(previously Incenter Mortgage Advisors).

“For 2022 [on MSR trading volume], my numbers were right around 1.1 trillion, and I expect 2023 to be slightly greater than that,” Piercy said. “However, I think it [trading volume] was front-end loaded over the first six to seven months of the year … but we continue to see the capital commitments to invest in MSR both from your traditional bank, and nonbank servicers, as well as the MSR investors. 

“And so, I’m still quite bullish on where we are today, as we forecast the capital and the ability to absorb the MSRs in the market.”



Source link


Today’s inflation reports show that Federal Reserve rate cuts are in play in 2024 — not because of the labor market breaking, but because real rates are too high. If the labor market gets weaker, meaning jobless claims break over 323,000 on the four-week moving average, we can get even more rate cuts. The labor market is not there yet so for now we can focus on the fact that the Fed overhiked, and because of that, they have room to cut. 

The Fed can’t avoid the reality that existing home sales are at record lows and the Fed should be pro-housing again, something I discussed on this HousingWire Daily podcast.

Let’s dig into the report to find out why the Fed can now discuss rate cuts for next year.

From BLS: The Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) increased 0.1 percent in November on a seasonally adjusted basis, after being unchanged in October, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. Over the last 12 months, the all-items index increased 3.1 percent before seasonal adjustment.

Tuesday’s report showed inflation was a bit stronger than anticipated, but it was boosted by rents and used car prices, both of which have longer-term disinflationary futures in store for them. If you take shelter inflation out of the equation, CPI is running at 1.4%, so the lagging shelter data keeps the CPI report artificially higher than it should be and the Fed knows this. Core CPI would be much lower today if we had real-time rent data.

Shelter inflation is also 44.4% of the index so it’s the most significant component of the CPI index. Back in September 2022 on CNBC, I talked about rents falling, which will be more of a positive story in 2023 as this data line lags badly. Everyone is on the same page on this and the chart below again shows shelter inflation being high but in real terms, it’s much lower than that today.

What does this mean for the Fed meeting on Wednesday? I am not a Fed pivot person: I don’t think the Fed will reverse course until the labor market breaks. So, when we are talking about rate cuts next year, that has to do more with the Fed over-hiking starting in 2022 to make sure the growth rate of inflation fell. With where inflation is going, they can cut rates a few times and still be in restrictive policy if the growth rate of inflation falls even more.

The 10-year yield has fallen dramatically from the recent peak of around 5%, currently at 4.22%. So, the market has loosened financial conditions a bit already but more needs to happen for housing to get going again. Mortgage rates should be below 6% today, but the spreads are still very restrictive in the mortgage market. With the growth rate of inflation falling, this needs to change.

What I would take away from today’s inflation data is that the trend is your friend: the growth rate of inflation has been falling for some time now. The Fed policy is still too restrictive for housing and hopefully the Fed gets a wake-up call and can be pro-housing once again, giving up it’s “stay-at-home” housing economic policy sooner than later.

It’s worth noting that inflation is falling without a job loss recession. Bond yields will head even lower if the labor market gets weaker as they won’t wait for the Fed to act. Hopefully, in tomorrow’s Fed meeting we will see that they’re on the same page and we can all land the plane.



Source link


In the mortgage business, November typically represents the start of the slow season. While mortgage rates cooled down significantly from October, it wasn’t enough to overcome seasonal, historic trends and low levels of inventory.

Lock volume declined 10% last month from October, driven by a 12% drop in purchase locks, according to Optimal Blue’s originations market monitor report

“Cooling economic indicators and dovish commentary from the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting at the beginning of November drove a rally in rates across mortgage products,” said Brennan O’Connell, data solutions manager at Optimal Blue. 

Following the Federal Reserve’s decision to hold rates steady in November, the spread between the 30-year conforming rate and the 10-year Treasury narrowed by 16 basis points (bps) to 274 bps – the lowest since March.

The Optimal Blue Mortgage Market Indices (OBMMI) 30-year conforming rate dropped 67 bps in November, finishing the month at 7.11%. Jumbo rates fell 34 bps to 7.61%, FHA dropped 54 bps to 6.90%, and VA dropped 61 bps to 6.79%.

The recent decline in rates incentivized borrowers who took out loans over the last few months to refinance – driving up refi volume by 2% month over month to reach its highest level since February.

The refinance climb included 10% month-over-month growth in rate/term refinance volume, while cash-out refi volume remained essentially flat from October. 

Purchase lock counts, which exclude the impact of changes in home prices, were down 13% year over year and 37% from pre-pandemic levels in 2019.

Nonconforming products – including jumbo and expanded guidelines loans – gave up share in November, dropping from 12% to 10% of total production month-over-month. 

Origination volume from FHA products rose to 23% of total production in November, up 1% from October. 

Other products remained mostly flat in production – including GSE-eligible products at 56%, VA products at 10%, and USDA products at 1%. 

The steep drop in rates drove down ARM shares to 6.5% in November from 7.9% in October.

Most metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs) experienced declines in rate lock volume, with the exception of Orlando, Florida (6%), which saw growth in production, and New York, New York (0.9%) and San Antonio, Texas (-0.5%), which both remained flat in month-over-month volume.

The average loan amount dropped to $347,400 from $352,500 and the average purchase price saw the largest decline since October 2022, falling to $438,300 in November from $449,300 the previous month. 

“Historic affordability issues are keeping buyers on the sideline and forcing sellers to reduce their expectations,” O’Connell added. “This may signal a downward trend in home prices after an extended period of steady growth.”



Source link


While sellers of existing homes have struggled with rising rates and softening demand, homebuilders have not only survived, but thrived in this market thanks to the use of mortgage rate buydowns, a tool more widely used by builders since their business is selling homes and clearing inventory. Research from the AEI Housing Center found that these buydowns are not only an effective tool to qualify income-constrained buyers and alleviate excess inventory, but they have also allowed builders to forgo home price cuts. 

The beginnings of mortgage rate buydowns

Homebuilders had a less-than-ideal beginning as 2022 dawned. After a long period of rate repression, the Federal Reserve began aggressive monetary tightening, which would ultimately send mortgage rates to their highest levels since 2000. As affordability worsened, potential buyers were forced to pull back. Meanwhile, inventory for new homes soared to levels last seen during the Great Financial Crisis as builders worked off the backlog accumulated from the pandemic’s construction boom.  

To overcome these headwinds, builders quickly turned to lowering mortgage rates through permanent rate buydowns — a tool last widely used in the early 1980s when the rates exceeded 12%.  This phenomenon becomes clearly apparent when compared to existing home sales, for which these buydowns are very rare. As shown in the chart below, existing and new home sales for the 19 largest home builders had roughly the same note rates until January 2022. However, once rates and inventory levels started to rise thereafter, a growing gap emerged between the two series. The gap peaked in November 2022, when the average note rate for new construction sales was one percentage point lower than the rate for existing home sales. As of July 2023, the gap had slightly narrowed to 0.8 ppt.

* Limited to loans with CLTV 76-80 and FICO 720-770 to control for the effect of loan level pricing adjustments.

Note: Data are for 30-year fixed rate primary-owner occupied purchase loans.

Source: AEI Housing Center, www.AEI.org/housing.

Rate buydowns helped builders ride out higher rates 

Their ability to effectively utilize buydowns in a high rate environment has provided homebuilders a competitive advantage: Not only are they able to sell more homes, they are also able to sell these homes without cutting prices. According to Census Bureau data, new home sales in September 2023 surged to the highest level since February 2022, while existing home sales plummeted. On top of that, prices for existing home sales had dropped noticeably, while prices for new home sales had slightly accelerated.

Based on AEI Housing Center’s constant-quality home price data, new home sale prices have far outpaced prices for existing homes during the high rate period — a clear trend reversal from the low rate period. From Jan. 2022 to Dec. 2022 (the latest data point available), existing home prices have appreciated by 3%, while new home prices have appreciated 14%. 

* Series ends in December 2022 because AVM tends to equal the sale price if the sale date is less than six months prior to the AVM date (June 2023 in this case). This particularly affects new home sales as they have fewer comparable sales.

Source: AEI Housing Center, www.AEI.org/housing.

Permanent rate buydowns through “bulk forward commitments”

Unlike individual home sellers, builders, due to their size and scale, were much better positioned to adapt to the new market conditions. Their use of rate buydowns is facilitated by the use of “bulk forward commitments,” where builders buy large pools of money at lower rates in advance. This can either be done by locking in rates as a hedge or by paying the lender a bulk buydown fee. Helping to absorb the cost of “bulk forward commitments” are builders’ strong profit margins during the housing boom following the pandemic. As we will demonstrate, permanent buydowns can achieve a similar level of affordability at a lower cost and less market impact than a price cut.  

The AEI Housing Center’s data clearly reveal the use of large-scale forward commitments through rate bunching at particular points. For example, in November 2022 when the average note rate for existing home sales was at 6.75%, almost 90% of new homes sold by DR Horton had a note rate below 6% with clear bunching at 3.99%, 4.75%, and 4.99%.  

Note: Data are for 30-year fixed rate primary-owner occupied purchase loans. Bin width is 0.125.

Source: AEI Housing Center, www.AEI.org/housing.

Why builders prefer rate buydowns over price reductions

There are three distinct reasons for homebuilders’ reliance on rate buydowns.

First, they are far more cost effective than a corresponding price cut. The math is straightforward: Imagine a builder selling a $400,000 home to a buyer making $100,000 a year. Assuming a 30-year fixed rate mortgage of 7% with 20% down payment, the monthly payment would be roughly $2,100. In this case, the total debt-to-income ratio (DTI) would be 51% and would exceed the Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac DTI limit of 50%.

To reduce the DTI to 48%, the builder would need to cut the sale price by 10%. Alternatively, the builder can offer a 1 ppts. permanent rate buydown to 6%. In both cases, the borrower’s monthly payment would drop to $1,900, which allows the borrower to qualify with a DTI below 50%. However, the cost to the builder with the buydown is only 3.2% of the sales price, or one-third of the cost of a price cut (see table).  On the other hand, offering free upgrades such as a marble countertop, another strategy commonly used by the builders, does not help bring down the borrower’s DTI at all.

Stylized comparison between a price cut and a mortgage rate buydown

OriginalPrice Cut1 ppt Rate Buydown
Home Price$400,000$360,000$400,000
% Down Payment20%20%20%
Loan Amount$320,000$288,000$320,000
Mortgage Rate7%7%6%
Monthly Payment$2,129$1,916$1,919
Income$100,000$100,000$100,000
Total Debt-to-Income Ratio51%48%48%
Cost to Builder$0$40,000(10% price cut)$12,800(3.2% of sales price)

Source: AEI Housing Center, www.AEI.org/housing.

Second, AEI Housing Center data reveal another facet of the builders’ buydown strategy: the use of bulk forward commitments as a tool to offer different rates, and ultimately customized “price cuts”, to different borrowers based on their ability to pay — a classic form of price discernment. For example, in November 2022 the average DTI for DR Horton’s FHA borrowers was 50% regardless of their mortgage rate. One would have expected lower DTIs for borrowers with lower rates as monthly mortgage payments and DTIs increase with higher mortgage rates all else equal. This suggests that DR Horton was offering the greatest buydowns to the most income-constrained borrowers in order to qualify more of them for financing. 

Finally, by avoiding actual price cuts, the past and future buyers still see the original price as the sales price, with the bought down rate being much harder to discern and quantify. 

Conclusion

Builders benefit from economies of scale that bestow them with advantages over individual home sellers during the current challenging market environment. Had builders not used rate buydowns, they may have been forced to slash prices as existing home sellers were forced to do. Meanwhile, the cost of rate buydowns is relatively low. Based on our back-of-the-envelope calculation, the average cost of buydowns for new homes sold between February 2022 and July 2023 is only around 1.3% of the sale price — a relative bargain for builders compared to a 5% price cut. 

So far, buydowns seem to have worked well to shield builders from price cuts. However, the home price data end in December 2022 and since then, mortgage rates have risen from 6.5% to nearly 8%. At these higher levels, it remains to be seen if rate buydowns alone are sufficient for builders to avoid price cuts. As of now, the story is mixed: While Evercore reported more builders raising base home prices than lowering them in October 2023, National Association of Home Builders survey data show contrasting trends. Ultimately, one needs to rely on the constant-quality home price data to gauge the comprehensive price trends, which we will continue to track.

  1.  According to the Census Bureau, months’ supply for new homes surged from 5.8 months in January 2022 to 10.1 months in July 2022.
  2.  Temporary rate buydowns, where the builder buys down the mortgage rate for only the first one to three years of the loan, is another tool used by the builders, albeit with less prevalence. Since the buydown is temporary, it does not improve borrower eligibility as the loan is underwritten at the permanent, not temporary, rate. According to our data, the share of temporary buydowns peaked in December 2022 at 9% and is back to 3% in July 2023.
  3.  The same trend applies to all new home sales, but the 19 largest builders are offering even lower rates, with DR Horton, Lennar and Pulte using rate buydowns most aggressively.
  4.  Unlike average home prices, such as the new home sale price from Census Bureau, constant-quality home price appreciation (HPA) is unaffected by the changes in the composition of homes sold and therefore more accurately reflects the home price trend.
  5.   See for example: John Burns.
  6.  According to Evercore Chart of the Week on April 14, 2023, starting this year, most builders classify rate buydowns as a reduction in selling price (ASP) on the profit and loss statement (P&L).
  7.  For this example, we are combining the monthly housing expense and other monthly debt obligations (assumed to be 25% of the borrower’s monthly income) to compute a total DTI. 
  8.  The estimate is based on new homes sold between February 2022 and July 2023. Data are limited to all FHA loans and conventional loans with CLTV 76-80 and FICO 720-770 to control for the effect of loan level pricing adjustments.
  9.  See Evercore Chart of the Week on November 17, 2023.

Sissi Li is senior data and analytics manager at AEI Housing Center.



Source link


You’ve been listening to all the BiggerPockets podcasts, reading the blogs, interacting on the forums, and going to all the meetups. Every day, you’re analyzing deals from the MLS and from wholesalers that you’ve met. You’re networking, learning, and doing all the right things, but it’s just not coming together. 

You need to make a change in your life for yourself and your family’s future, and there’s no room for error here. How do people do this, starting from scratch?

The biggest thing holding you back that you haven’t even considered is your car payment. 

Check Your Car Payment

Many investors are looking for deals that cash flow at least a bit—maybe a couple of hundred dollars per door or so. Nerdwallet reports that in 2022, the average used car payment in America was $516. And new cars? A whopping $725. 

That’s per month, folks—and it’s the average. Stack that on top of the fact that most families have two cars, even if they were used, and that’s an average of $1,032 per month in car payments. 

How would you like that cash flow? Well, you could have it tomorrow if you got rid of those car payments. 

“But I need my car to get to work!” Do you mean that job that you are trying to get rid of? Seriously, there are so many alternatives: drive a junker, ride a bike or a skateboard, walk, public transportation, or carpool. The options are endless. 

Think about this critically: Why do you need that car payment? I mentor many aspiring investors in my market, and nine times out of 10, they pull up in a nicer car than I have. I always ask about it, and the answer is always the same: Either they “need” it for work, or they need a “safe” car for their family. 

Well, sure, a 2010 Camry is nominally less safe than a 2022 Tesla Model Y, with all its fancy navigation panels and automatic this and that. But do you really need the latter?

Or you might say, “I’m a contractor, and I need my truck.” If you are a contractor making less than $150,000, the last thing you need is a $1,200 truck payment. The bed of a 2008 F150 can haul a box of nails just as well as a 2023 F350 with a lift. 

Why Real Estate in the First Place?

Before we delve further into the car payment conundrum, let’s talk about real estate investment and why it’s a savvy financial move.

Real estate is a proven asset class for building wealth over time. Unlike cars, which depreciate in value the moment you drive them off the lot, real estate has the potential to appreciate, generating wealth through both property value increases and rental income.

Here are a few reasons why real estate is an attractive investment:

  • Steady income: If you invest in rental properties, you can enjoy a consistent stream of income from your tenants.
  • Appreciation: Real estate tends to appreciate over the long term, increasing the value of your investment.
  • Tax benefits: There are numerous tax advantages to owning real estate, including deductions for mortgage interest, property taxes, and depreciation.
  • Diversification: Real estate offers diversification in your investment portfolio, reducing risk.
  • Leverage: You can use financing (mortgages) to purchase real estate, allowing you to control a valuable asset with a relatively small upfront investment.

Delaying Gratification

With car payments, the inverse is true in every single one of these real estate benefits. How can we say that we believe that real estate is an obvious path to wealth while we are working a W-2 job and driving a car well beyond our financial means?

Honestly, we all need to check our egos. In American culture, cars have always been one of the statements we make about ourselves, and car manufacturers have done a great job of taking advantage of that weakness in all of us. When was the last time you used that $1,500 built-in drink cooler in your armrest? It sure seems like an alluring option when you are rolling into your car payment. 

There are no shortcuts in real estate, and we all know the way to win in life is through delayed gratification. Why should having your dream car be any different? 

You can absolutely have your dream car, whatever that may be, but you can have it later. If you don’t have enough passive income to cover those payments, you need to examine your budget. If you stopped working your W-2 job tomorrow, how long could you keep making your housing payments, insurance, living expenses, and car payments? If the answer is not “forever,” then you need to get that car sold yesterday and find another way to get around. 

Now, back to the high car payments and their impact on real estate investment. One of the primary culprits here is the need for immediate gratification. We live in a world of instant everything—fast food, on-demand streaming, and, yes, even instant car loans. It’s all too easy to succumb to the desire for immediate rewards, like driving off in a fancy new car.

However, this desire for instant gratification often comes at the expense of future happiness. When you commit a significant portion of your monthly income to car payments, you have less money available for investing. It becomes a vicious cycle: You buy a pricey car to satisfy your immediate desires, but in doing so, you limit your capacity to invest in assets like real estate that can truly change your life for the better. 

All of that, and we haven’t even begun to discuss the debt-to-income (DTI) ratio. When people with average incomes begin to invest and scale, the limiting factor that will smack them in the face the quickest is being shut down by conventional lenders due to their high DTI. If you make $80,000 per year and have a $500 car payment, you’ll struggle to find a conventional lender who will be able to help you scale. 

I know, I know—private money and DSCR loans are where it’s at. Sure, but DSCR loans are really tough to get those ratios on right now, with 8% and higher interest rates. 

Newer investors always want the best deal, and conventional loans are always going to be the best rates and terms available—that rate and those terms are what will make your deal cash flow or not. If you want the best pricing on your loans, you need to free up as much DTI as you possibly can. Getting rid of your car payment is a painless way to make a big dent. 

Opportunity Cost: What Could You Be Missing?

To put this in perspective, let’s consider the concept of opportunity cost—what you forego by choosing one option over another. In this case, the opportunity cost of having car payments could be substantial.

Imagine you have a $700 monthly car payment. Over the course of a year, that’s $8,400. Now, what if you took that $8,400 and put it into a brokerage account to save a down payment on an investment property or contributed it to a retirement account? Over time, that money could grow significantly through compound interest or real estate appreciation.

In contrast, the car you purchased will lose value year after year. It’s a classic case of prioritizing short-term feelings over long-term freedom.

Finding Balance

The key takeaway here is to find a balance between your immediate desires and long-term financial goals. 

If you’re itching for a new car, set yourself an income goal that will pay for the car. For instance, if you buy three properties that cash flow $250 per door over three years, your car with a $750 payment is essentially “free.” Your tenants bought it for you.

High car payments, driven by the need for immediate gratification, are very likely to hinder your ability to invest in real estate. While the allure of a shiny new car is undeniable, it’s crucial to weigh that desire to have a shiny new car now against your goal of being financially independent. Is it really worth it?

By finding a balance between satisfying your short-term desires and earning a financially free future, you can ensure that you’re not just driving in style today but also building a solid foundation for tomorrow. It’s not about denying yourself pleasures; it’s about making choices that align with the future that you build for yourself. It starts today.

Ready to succeed in real estate investing? Create a free BiggerPockets account to learn about investment strategies; ask questions and get answers from our community of +2 million members; connect with investor-friendly agents; and so much more.

Note By BiggerPockets: These are opinions written by the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of BiggerPockets.



Source link


Cleveland, Ohio-based fintech Upright has launched a debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) rental loan to investors, the company announced on Monday. 

DSCR rental loans are non-qualifying mortgages (non-QMs) used by real estate investors to qualify for a loan based on their property’s cash flow without personal income verification. 

“Many customers at first come to us for our fix and flip loans. Often, their exit strategy was to turn them into long-term rental properties, and we have previously had to refer them elsewhere. There was a piece of the puzzle missing,” Brendan Bennett, Upright’s vice president of revenue, said in a statement.

According to Bennett, the DSCR rental loans will serve Upright’s customers throughout their real estate investment journey.

The new product offers real estate investors access to at least $75,000 in 15- and 30-year fixed mortgages, adjustable rate mortgages (ARMs) and interest-only options. Loan-to-value is up to 80% for purchase or rate-and-term refinance or up to 75% in cash-out refinance.

At Upright, the DSCR rental loan is available for borrowers with a minimum 640 credit score. The loan is available for single-family residences, including modular, 2-4 unit residences, condominiums, townhomes and multi-family properties up to 10 units. 

No debt-to-income considerations or personal or business income verification are required. However, the loan is only subject to rental income. 

Upright provides real estate investors with software tools, capital and passive income opportunities. The company, founded in 2014, acquired software as a service product Flipper Force in 2022. It said it managed more than $2 billion in investments. 



Source link